It was an old thread but I eventually tried both of them last weekend... I am on the Magnum XL side. That's all folks!
LOL, Since getting a vasectomy, I've never needed condoms, but I wondered aout the XL's. I have the same girth as you, so this site just saved me some cash and time. Thanks.
Never found a condom that works for my thickness (over 7.5") but the Magnum XL works OK for a quickie. After 20 minutes, the big guy looks a little black and blue... I've tried durex XXL and they seem just about the same as the Magnum. G.
Agreed with you here, OP. Magnum XL's ONLY, and they are still a bit too tight (but infinitely better, obviously, than other brands). To me, they are a good, quality product, and not a bad price (since they are saving my life, in more ways than one.....). Yes, I wished they made a more "custom" size, but the profit margins would be low enough they wouldn't make them for long, or in any quantity.
for years I suffered with condom problems, couple of years back found Magnum XLs and never looked back, my condom of choice