A list of sizes according to my research.
Remember even if guys dildos are accurate molds, they could be longer than the insertable length even NBP depending on their anatomy.
And obviously some guys would be less than their dildo if the molds were exaggerated.
I have used thousands of pictures, sources, replica dildos etc. to make my estimations
This is for NBP length, and midshaft/average girth when said pornstar is in shape because this is what I think is the fairest way to measure the dick (So add 0.5 for bonepressed measurements)
I'm very confident about my sizes being close to the truth but I am open to debate:
If the sizes are in conflict with other posts, it means I disagree with the points made. I have seen this whole thread and people tend to either use unflattering angles, pixel counting when a dick is above parallel etc or using obviously lower than NBP insertable length from dildos when balls got in the way to suit their guesses if it's a ridiculously low estimate.
I'm probably more on the "realist" side than the ridiculous fools claiming people are 10+ inches or the lying Jonah Falcons of the world (who I don't even bother to list, but trust me he's not bigger than the top guys on this list and likely smaller).
But I'm also tired of the agenda driven guys knocking people down a peg for no reason. Be consistent.
Mr: 18: 9x6
Mandingo: 9x5.75 (Note: this does mean a few guys have more volume than Mandingo, especially as I think he is closer to 5.75 girth than 6 which is what I originally thought. But he is definitely the longest that gets fully hard though with decent erection angle which is why most consider him the king of big cock porn, as Mr. 18 looks basically impotent. Girth does matter more than length, but if you're girth is at least somewhat good and proportional to the length, being the "longest" is kind of synonymous with the "biggest" at least from a visual standpoint , even if not so for female pleasure.)
Julio Gomez: 8.75x6.25
Jack Napier: 8.5x6.25
John Holmes: 8.5x6
Danny D: 8.25x5.75
Lex Steele: 8.25x5.5
White Pony: 8x6
Richard Mann: 8x6
Ramon: 7.75x6.25
Shane Diesel: 7.5x6.5
Clover: 7.5x5.5
Criss Strokes: 7.25x5.25
Sean Michaels: 7.25x5.25
Julian Rios: 7.25x5.75
Steve Holmes: 7.25x5.5
Chris Charming: 7.25x6 (huge head though, looks thicker than most 6 inch girth guys due to this)
Mick Blue: 7.25x5.25
Johnny Sins: 7x5.25 (probably most overrated guy in terms of size, but he does have the best body in straight porn. His girth isn't as small as some say though)
Rocco Siffredi: 7x6
Ben English: 7x6
Prince Yahshua: 7x6, (same dick as Rocco just curved upward more and black, some got 6.8 in some pics, but I felt they were robbing him a bit due to erection angle)
Mark Wood: 6.75x6 (big head, similar dick to Charming but not as long)
James Deen: 6.75x5.5
Mr. Marcus :6.75x5.6 (specific girth based on dildo, sounds accurate)
Shorty Mac: 7x6.75 (Thickest dick in porn history. Not as thick as he looks at 1st due to wide and flat shape, but still thicker than anyone else ever. Clearly a priapism "victim". His size is very hard to peg exactly due to the odd shape and small, deflated head (both in length and girth) You could argue reasonably for 6.75x7 as well as the 7x6.75 I have him at!
Nacho Vidal: 6.75x6.25 (huge girth, upward curve, great dick)
Billy Glide 6.75x6.5 (Like Nacho but circumcised, noticeably thicker, although head isn't as big, and less of a curve/upward angle. One of the 4 or 5 thickest dicks ever seen in porn, and maybe the most impressive as he was always hard)
Jez Christ: 6.75x6.5 (Same as Billy but uncut British actor with more of an upward curve shape. Also got hard which is rare for very thick guys. Massive girth tied among the biggest, only decisively 2nd to Shorty Mac)
Brian Pumper: 6.5x6
Mike Adriano: 6.5x6
Manuel Ferrara: 6.5x6.1 (Specific girth based on a dildo measurement. A precise measurement of the dildo seemed to indicate 6.06 and a hair (6 1/16th), but it's very hard to tell when slight differences in angle of tape etc. can make a small difference. To be fair I will give the listed 6.1 measurement and round him up 4/100th of an inch
).
There are quite a few guys less than 6.5 or less than 5 girth but this is a good start for now.
What do you guys think?