This is where you're blind, if Rob started a Men's Issues Forum then he could put all the threads that drive the women nuts into a compressed folder out of your view and out of your way, which is what's already being done with the Women's Issues Forum.
This would free up much needed space for broader ideas to expand and grow on the site.
Thus, the men don't have to bother with Women's Issues and the same for the women, they won't have to bother with all the Men's Issues which would lead to a less frustrating site.
I'm not saying a Men's Issues forum is a bad thing - but I too am amongst those who can't see what would go in it that doesn't already have a home here. Maybe if there were some examples of what the forum would contain there would be less scepticism?
I'm also struggling to see the double standards - if a woman wanted to discuss, I don't know mammogram experiences and posted it in 'Healthy Penis', it would be moved to 'Women's Issues'. This is in the same way other posts are moved from Women's Issues to Relationships, etc.
One of the main problems seems to be (and this is only my opinion) that some threads get started in the Women's Issue's forum in an attempt to solicit responses from women - not because they are 'women's issues'. Sometimes this is even acknowledged by the OP who started the thread.
Herein lies part of the problem - a proportion of the women steer clear of 'Sex With A Large Penis' and the other forums
on purpose - they know where to find it if they want it, they just don't want it for whatever reason - be it general tone of the forum, specific posters, whatever.
Yes, this may reduce the number of women who will see/respond to posts, but to deliberately post an unsuitable thread in Women's Issues is kind of forcing it down people's throats and implies that because someone desires a response from women, the women are under an obligation to provide one. I honestly think that the 'Ask a Woman' forum will make a huge difference - that way if someone wants to target their question to women they can and those women minded to respond can.
JMO.