My Straight Brothers Week at Fire Island.

[Xyke]

I love where this is going, thanks @gtru1981

 

[miamirt]

Lovin it

 

[Simplez]

more

 

[gtru1981]

Hi everyone, we are starting to wrap up the story, with two more chapters left:


Chapter 18: More Secrets Revealed (Henry’s Point of View)
As Anthony kept dragging me away from the large crowd from the bar and closer to the pier, I was still in shock at what just happened. As we got closer to the pier, all around us, were groups of guys, drinking, making out or having sex. On the bench, I was looking at this muscular blonde goddess getting deepthroated by this skinny twink. I was snapped out of it, when being pushed against the light pole.

“Henry, I have known you for years, you’re like a brother to me.” Anthony said

I nodded to his question and gave him a confused look, as I didn’t know where this was going. Just then, Anthony grabbed me and planted a kiss on my lips and I pushed him off.

“What the fuck Ant, what was that for?”

“It's funny, I was having this not to nice conversation with that piece of shit Lee. He informed me, the reason we didn’t work out, was because you were in love with me.” Anthony said, while giggling.

“However, I knew he was full of shit, because I have always known for years, I wasn’t the Caruso you were in love with. I have known you have been in love with Thomas all this time.” Anthony said, while now crossing his arms with a serious look.

I stood there now, leaning my back against the light pole at a loss of words.

“Why did you go to California with my brother to pay that wannabe crackhead actor to seduce Lee, resulting in him dumping me? I get why Tommy did it?
You do anything that he asks you to, you follow him like a little puppy. Funny part, I am not even mad, Lee wasn’t good for me.” Anthony said in a very calm manner.

Anthony then takes out his phone and opens up this app. He asked me if I remember my uncle installing security cameras around the house, which I totally forgot a few years ago. He showed me the clip of me and Tommy from the previous night, in the hot tub and all those guys at the house a few hours ago.

“I been noticing both Lex and Tommy beating themselves up, it doesn't make them gay by any means, if by all means they wanted to try it and that is all. If they never, do it again, they are not even bisexual. Most guys try it once, they see an opportunity to try it.

However, they are not finding the right guys. That is why I did what I had to do, get Lex and Tommy to fool around with each other, they are comfortable with one another.” Anthony said.

Then, he got closer to me and started to whisper in my ear.

“I know for a fact, neither are 100% straight! Let me tell you two little secrets. The night before Lex was about to get married, he came to my apartment drunk and we made out. He went on to say how he has these feelings for me and if he was single, he would be with me.

Also, remember when my mother and Tommy caught me at 16 years old with the next-door neighbor Chad Deluca. Well, the night of my brother's bachelor party, when I hooked up with Chad and fucked him hard and deep, he let it slip, he and Tommy use to fool around in high school!”

My eyes widened about these two facts I didn’t know, as Anthony backed away and slapped my cheeks hard and laughed.

“Now Henry, I think we have made everything hot and bothered, let's go get them! Anthony laughed to himself.

With a smirk on his face, Anthony started to head back to the bar and I had to get myself together, with all this information I was told. Yes, Tommy is the love of my life and I have waited years to be with him. Could this actually finally happen and we end up together?

However, I also have this fear, what if Tommy doesn’t like being with a guy? My heart would be broken, but FUCK IT, I will not know until I find out. I need to take that chance and stop being a pussy!

 

[redsxkid]

and?

 

[gtru1981]

Chapter 19 (Tommy’s Point of View) - IT FINALLY HAPPENS!​

I woke up, dazed, hung over, confused and in pain. As I turned around, biting my lip from the pain, I saw Henry sitting there on the side of my bed, looking at his iPad.

“Good morning sunshine! You finally woke up! I have some toast, juice, coffee, water and ibuprofen for your drunk ass.

You sure took a major stumble last night at the bar. Do you even know, its 3 pm?” Henry said without even looking away from his iPad.

“What the fuck happened last night?” I asked, as the room was spinning.

“Well, during your little porn scene with Lex on top of the bar, after you two blow your loads, you were trying to get down from the bar. However, you slipped on a huge wad of cum on the bar and fell to the ground with Lex falling on top of you.” Henry said, while laughing and showing me the clip of when it happened.

I slammed my head onto my pillow, remembering what happened last night. I remember making out with Lex and the incredible blowjob, he gave me. Henry went on to say, he will check back on me throughout the day and to get some rest.

I ended up falling asleep and woke up the next day. I felt a little better, little pain, but the massive headache and hangover was gone. I found some of my underwear and headed to the kitchen. There, I saw Henry eating breakfast, with a book. It was 8 in the morning.

“Hey sleepy head, feeling better?” Henry asked.

“I feel a lot better; I needed that sleep. Where is everyone?

Henry went on to tell me, Lex and Ant went to bring Timmy and Rodrigo to the ferry, as they were headed back to the mainland. After that, they were going to hang out by the beach, to soak up some sun before their trip was over. Henry just came back from running on the beach and was about to hit the shower. I will say, after my sexual awakening with Lex, I couldn’t stop stirring at shirtless and sweaty Henry. My cock was starting to twitch in my underwear and Henry was noticing it.

“I was about to take a shower from my run, do you want to join me?” Henry asked with the most seductive eyes I ever seen.

Henry got up and walked past me, heading to the bathroom. I heard him turn on the shower and I stood there in the kitchen. As I was standing there, I started to think of what happened to Lex and I a few nights ago. I have known for a very long time; Henry has a thing for me. Thinking back of the drunken confession during my bachelor party and the wedding rehearsal party, where Henry confessed his love to me.

As I opened the door to the bathroom, the hot steam from the shower was fogging up the room and my view. As I pulled my underwear down, I slowly entered the shower and was standing behind Henry. I wrapped my arms around his body, as my cock was now pressing on his beautiful muscular ass. I grabbed hold of him tight, kissing his neck and Henry let out a soft moan and titled his head backwards. I push his body closer to mine, where my cock was now resting between his butt cheeks.

I whispered into Henry’s eye to keep his eyes closed, as I started to nibble on his ears and lowered my arms to his waist. As the water keeps hitting our bodies from the shower head, the hot water kept steaming up the room, as it became very warm. While still nibbling, kissing, and licking Henry’s neck and ear, I slowly start to caress his wet body

“I am going to fuck your brains out!” I whispered into Henry’s ear.

I then turn him around, tug his thick and hard cock a few times before planting a kiss on his wet, but still soft lips. We stand there in the shower for a few seconds, while our noses are touching.

“I am sorry it took me this long for us to get here. I know I've been giving you mixed signals all these years, but I am ready, ready to show you how much you mean to me.” I say in a very low voice, while breathing loudly.

I heard Henry start to whimper, as I felt one of his wet hands run up my back, up to my shoulder. He started to push me back slowly, so our eyes were looking directly at each other. He had this playful, yet lustful look on his face that drove me crazy. We both now leaned in, as our lips were brushing against each other; he took the first step and pressed our lips together.

As Henry pushed his tongue deep inside my mouth, our tongues entwined, and we started to make out. Soft moans were coming from both of us and our hands were now jerking each other's massive hard cocks, while making out. We were now both moaning loudly, as I bit the lower lip of this fuckin sexy guy.

Slowly, I pushed Henry down to his knees, as he briefly kissed my abs, before he got to my leaking cock, dripping of precum. Henry quickly looked up at my now seductive eyes, as he was holding on to my cock.

"Don't worry. Just leave everything to me." Henry said as I felt the wet warmth of his mouth devouring my cock.

It was his amazing and talented tongue. He was licking in circular motions, and sucking every so often, while playing with my heavy balls. He stopped for a quick second and slowly spread my legs. Out of nowhere, he started to massage my hole and then inserted a finger. It felt weird, but amazing at the same time, I let out a huge moan.

"Enjoying yourself" Henry whispered looking at me.

He continued to wrap his lips around my almost about to burst cock, while continuing to play with my ass. My hips thrusted forward in reaction, and one of my hands reached down and started to play with his wet hair. I threw my head back and my jaw dropped, gasping and moaning like a porn star. I felt another one of his fingers slide inside me and I didn't protest, instead I whimpered because it felt so good. What he was doing to me were new things, that were making my toes curl, making me scream out loud, so loud the birds in the backyard heard and flew away. I was about to cum, but I didn’t want to.

I lifted him up, kissed him on the lips, turned him over, where his face was now facing the steaming wet tile walls and spread his legs. I slowly lower myself, while kissing, licking, and biting his back, until I was facing his round and muscular butt cheeks. I slap his ass a few times, making him giggle and spread those luscious cheeks and stick my tongue out. I had no clue what I was doing, so I was trying to mimic what Henry did before.

I first teased his hungry hole with my finger before inserting it. It drove Henry crazy! His breathing started to get heavy, as he was starting to whine that he needs me tongue in his hole. After teasing him for a few minutes with my fingers, I stuck my tongue between his cheeks and started to lick his hole. After a few minutes of fingering, licking and sucking his hole, I got up.

“Yeah, I loved it when you rimmed my ass, however, not a fan of doing it to you babe, sorry!” I spoke.

“It’s alright, it's not for everyone. Let's get out of the shower, as my hands are starting to prune and head to the bedroom.” Henry said, after kissing me.

We would get out of the shower and dry one another off, which was a hard task I will say, as we kept kissing one another. Henry would lead me to the bedroom, tagging on my swollen cock and pushing us on the bed and we started to make out once again. He finally broke away and stood up, looking down at me while I admired his naked body in front of me.

He got off the bed and headed towards the night stand and got a bottle of lube. He grabbed the lube from my nightstand, while I was on my back. Henry than, lubed up my cock and was squatting over me, I now had my hands on his hips as he started to slowly lower himself onto my awaiting cock.

“Tommy, it's been a while since I been fucked, please be gentle, while I slide down on your cock, so my hole can get used to it. You’re extremely thick!” Henry said, as he was starting to lower his body down.

“I promise not to hurt you, however please let me fuck you!” I said, as I couldn’t wait any longer.

After that, Henry started to adjust to the size of my monster cock and started to bounce up and down. My eyes rolled back as Henry was so tight. I started to thrust up into him and after a few minutes we were in perfect rhythm. We were both moaning and groaning. Without warning, I sat up and in one quick motion I flipped him on his back with his legs straight in the air.

My throbbing and hungry cock never left his tight ass. I began to speed up, as Henry was grabbing ahold of the sweat covered bed sheets, with the please I was giving him. Henry kept mumbling and moaning loader and loader. His cock was flopping between mine and his stomachs, as I can tell he was about to blow his load soon. I wasn’t going to last much longer either, with the tightness of his hole.

Beads of sweat ran down our bodies, as I kept pounding my little brother's best friend and stretching his hole out. Henry took a pillow and placed it over his face, to try to cover up the loud moans and swearing he was doing. He also planted his hands on my sweaty chest, as I was driving my cock deeper into his hole. With one of my hands, I gently stroked Henry’s cock and out of nowhere, he was spraying his load all over my chest. One of his many shots of cum, even landed on my face, which I licked right off with my tongue.

With that, I blew 8 to 9 of my thick creamy cum deep into his hole, at one point when I was moaning of cumming, I blacked out for a few seconds of the pure pleasure that was accruing. Shivers were coming down my spine, as my now cock was softing and leaving Henry’s cum soaked gaping hole.

I fell forward and laid on top of Henry’s sweaty chest, as we shared a deep kiss. Once we caught our breath, I rolled onto the bed beside him.

“WOW, holy shit, that was intense!” I said, still trying to catch my breath.

“You could say that.” Henry chuckled at what just happened.

We both laid there for a few minutes, in silence, as we tried to catch our breath and process what just happened. After a few minutes, I felt Henry’s fingers going up and down my arm and he whispered to me, round two? We ended up ripping the sweaty, soaked up sheets, from all the intense fucking that was happening. After the third and final session, Henry collapsed into my arms and we ended up cuddling, wondering how a cum shot hit the ceiling.

 

[ndamood4sum]

This kinda weirded me out actually, if you're having this special connection with someone and freaked out when they make a move on you, then tell them you feel some spark and chemistry between the two of you. Fire island or not you're not supposed to forget your inhibitions and have a threesome with 2 random guys that you've met a day or two before, regardless how nice or kind they are. Maybe it's just me but I believe that "first time" specially in this situation should be with someone special for him, the lex part I get it since he's been curious about it and he doesn't have the spark yet with anyone. Still a good story tho, kudos to @gtru1981

I personally did not like the idea of he and Henry fooling around in the first place. I kind of think your friends probably should not be hooking up with your brother no matter what. Would have been cool if Tommy would have hooked up with another guy (no one in the friend group) and been caught and would have enjoyed that dynamic.

I did think about the fact he was about to have a threesome with two random guys when he had that entire conversation with Henry was strange. Although against it, I would assume his first (real) guy on guy experience would have been with Henry. I am thinking though the friend Henry rushed off to help was Anthony after the encounter with Lee and maybe the threesome will get interrupted before it gets full on. But I guess we'll see.

 

[ndamood4sum]

Chapter 16: It finally Happens!
As they started to gently kiss, Tommy noticed the noises from the crowd were starting to fade away. Lex begins to run his tongue against Tommy’s lips, gently forcing them to open. Both of their tongues began to rub together, as they started to make out. The slow, gentle, yet hot make out session was getting the people in the crowd attention now. The audience, while quiet for the most part, they did have their moments, where they went wild, seeing what was taking place on top of the bar. Both Lex’s and Tommy’s cocks were starting to throb now, with their precum starting to leak through their shorts.

Phil, the bartender, who had front row seating to this, made an involuntary moan, escaping from his lips as he watched the two of them make out. Lex once again moaned, as he seemed to be getting more turned on by the second as Tommy’s tongue explored his mouth.

"Fuck! This is beyond hot!" Lex whispered into Tommy’s ear, as he took a quick break, to nibble on his ear and neck.

Tommy groaned softly as he kissed Lex again, as he opened his mouth slowly, feeling his wet tongue interlocking with Lex’s tongue. They began to slowly rub their tongues together as Tommy was enjoying the make out session, as was the crowd.

As hot as things were becoming, not just for Lex and Tommy, but for the ever-growing crowd that was witnessing this. The bartenders started to shift the spotlights on the two straight guys making out, making the heat from the lights start to make them sweat. Lex, while still passionately making out with Tommy, slowly took off his tank top. As much as Lex wanted more of his clothing to come off, it dawned on him that they were outside and in front of a massive crowd. This fact seems to dawn on Tommy as well, as Lex gently pulled away from their hot make out session, with his shirt falling back down, covering his sweaty abs.

“FUCK!" Tommy said out loud

Tommy started to caress Lex’s face with one hand and gently squeezed his lips together with another.

"Fuck you're so hot!" Lex said as he pushed their bodies even closer.

As Lex slid his tongue back into Tommy’s mouth, his hands slid underneath Tommy’s tank, slipping it over his head and removing it. Now both straight hunks were shirtless, dripping in sweat, as the crowd now cheered them on. Tommy felt his abs quiver and jumped, when Lex started to rub his fingers all over his chest and brushed against his sensitive nipples.

Lex’s hands continued to roam, caressing Tommy’s chest, abs, making him feel incredible and alive. Tommy leaned back against the pillar of the bar, moaning. Lex stopped to unbutton his shorts and he pressed his muscular body against Tommy’s body, as their lips met again.

Tommy whispered into Lex’s ear and informed him, let's give the crowd what they have been wanting for a while, as he slid Lex’s shorts down and his cock sprung free, rock hard, and leaking massive amounts of precum. Lex felt Tommy’s hand slide against his throbbing cock, now massaging the tip. Both of the straight guys, looked into the crowd, as they saw Anthony whisper into Henry’s ear, as they started to fade back into the crowd.

If I were Henry, I would have been devastated and walked away at this point. Tommy is making his rounds with the guys and right in front of Henry which Is very disappointing, especially if Tommy has known all along that Henry was in love with him

 

[Di_No]

Little bit of reader pressure creeping in maybe.

 

[gtru1981]

Here it is everyone, the final (or maybe not) of this story. We shall see

Chapter 20 (Anthony’s Point of View) -The Final Chapter.

After the crazy 4th of July party and drama, the last two days were extremely relaxing, as our week was coming to an end on Fire Island. My dumbass brother was in bed for a full day, due to him slipping on some cum and flying off the bar top. Today was Wednesday, July 6th and Lex and I were taking Timmy and Rodrigo to the ferry, as they were handed back into the city.

Lex and the rest of the group just relaxed yesterday, by the pool, played board games and grilled some steaks. After we dropped off the boys, Lex and I decided to head to the beach, to relax and be alone. This is where I finally am going to confess my love to Lex and see where things potentially could go or turn out to be a disaster.

It was a beautiful, warm, sunny day at the beach. The crowds were still huge, but many people were returning back to their regular lives, as “new meat” was entering the island. I sat there, on the towel, having my toes dig themselves into the sand, as I watched Lex doing flips in the ocean water. Ever since the free peep show the crowd saw, thanks to me, Lex has been Mr. Popular.

As I saw Lex getting out of the water, I was looking at everyone looking at him, as the water from the ocean was dripping down his muscular body. Also, Lex was wearing some really tight see thru shorts, so that everyone could see the outline of his huge, thick, uncut cock. It was turning me on that everyone was eye fucking him and it made my cock start to twitch. Lex got to where I was and asked for a towel to dry off. I couldn’t stop laughing and Lex made sure to give everyone a show.

“Want to grab some lunch and make it a picnic date? There is this cute, quiet and romantic place we can go.” Lex said, while showcasing his adorable dimples.

The thing is, between today and yesterday, I have gotten to know Lex on a whole different level. I thought I knew everything about Alexander Rivera, however in the last 48 hours, I got to know him on a whole different level, the private side of himself. I never knew Lex was part of a cover band on Staten Island, or that he has been playing the drums since he was 14 years old. I got to know the softer side of him and I liked it.

After our romantic picnic Lex and I had, we decided to take a stroll by the water, as it was such a beautiful day. We ended up spending hours just walking up and down the beautiful beach, holding hands and getting to know each other.

“So, Ant, after this trip, where do you see us? I have known for a while; you had a crush on me.
Want to hear a little secret? I have been crushing you for a long time as well.” Lex whispered into my ear.

I just stood there, as the waves were crashing, people were laughing and the sun was now starting to come down.

“I was thinking Anthony, once we get back into the city, we go on a real date. Ever been to 4 Charles Prime Rib?” Lex asked.

That is like one of the hardest places to get a reservation in the city!” I spoke.

“Don’t you worry about that babe; my cousin is the manager there. How about this Saturday night, around 8 pm?
Maybe after that, we go to the Minskoff Theatre, where the Lion King is being played. After their 8 pm show, the cast and crew can give us a private performance.
Just let me know.” Lex said, with a sexy grin on his face, while gripping my hand and caressing my thumb.

Before I could respond, Lex went on to say, “I really care about you Anthony and I think this was something that has been brewing for a very long time.
I want to take this slow and not rush into anything. I am still new at certain things, like having sex with a guy, aka butt sex. I hope you can understand this and bear with me and let nature take its course.”

We ended up both sitting there on the beach, watching the sun start to come down. Lex was behind me, as he hugged me and kept whispering cute little things into my ear. As the sun was finally setting, we both turned to each other’s eyes and slowly our lips locked. For the first time in a very long time, I was extremely happy and told Lex I was in no rush and couldn’t wait for the weekend.

 

[gtru1981]

The Conclusion:
It's been a year since that weekend on Fire Island. Anthony was packing up for this coming 4th of July weekend getaway. A lot has changed over the last year. Ever since that weekend a year ago, he and Lex have been in a wonderful and healthy relationship. A few months after the trip, Anthony’s father, Vincenzo, would have a mild heart attack. This would result in Anthony moving back to Staten Island to be closer to his father, to help around. This gave Lex, now 34 years old, to ask Anthony to move in with him, since his house was a few doors down from his parents.

While Anthony was packing up his stuff for the weekend, Lex would come out of the bathroom.

“Hey babe, turn around, I have something to show you.” Lex said

As Anthony turns around, Lex, completely naked, starts wiggling his body and doing a little dance. Anthony knows the little dance very well; Lex is looking for a quicky. Anthony comes closer and wraps his arms around his boyfriends' hips and pushes him closer to him, where his cock starts to grow.

“Oh Mr. Rivera, looks like something needs some attention!” Anthony whispers seductively in his boyfriend's ear.

As Anthony removed his hand from caressing Lex’s chest, he now put his hands on his bf’s muscular arms and eventually slid them down to where their fingers would intertwine. He slowly guided Lex’s hand, causing their bodies to pull even closer together. Anthony, unlocking his hands, was now guiding them against Lex’s recently trimmed pubes. As both their nipples were now hard and Lex was starting to drip precum, Anthony started to massage Lex’s balls and quickly dropped down to his knees.

Anthony looked up and locked eyes with his boyfriend and slowly licked the tip of his cock, licking the precum off his cock. Lex spread his legs, closed his eyes and tilted his head backwards. Anthony with his left hand, was massaging Lex’s balls, while his right-hand index finger started to tease his hole.

Anthony wrapped his lips around Lex’s cock head and slowly took Lex’s full-length cock into his mouth. Lex let out a moan, as Anthony slowly sucked back and forth. After a few minutes of teasing his boyfriend, he started to deep throat his boyfriend cock.

After about 5 minutes of bobbing back and forth, hearing all the slurping and saliva coming out of Anthony’s mouth, he would let Lex’s cock pop out from his mouth, as he looked up at this boyfriend, while his hand reached below his balls and a finger once again touched his asshole. After licking Lex’s now sweaty stomach, Anthony once again started to deepthroat Lex’s now aching cock and balls, as he made small circles around Lex’s hole with his finger. Lex spread his legs wider, as the sensation was driving him crazy and he was getting close.

Lex was now moaning like crazy, while playing with his hard and sensitive nipples. He didn’t know how much longer he would last. Anthony continued to play with his asshole, with his fingers and continued to deepthroat his cock.

"I am getting close babe!" Lex hissed to his boyfriend, as he could feel the orgasm building and about to explode.

Anthony kept on sucking, faster and faster, as he kept going, bobbing his head back and forth on Lex’s cock. He then inserted his finger into his boyfriend's hole, which resulted in him letting out a very loud moan as he started to explode into Anthony's hungry mouth. Lex could feel his cock feeding his juices into Anthony’s mouth. Lex fed his boyfriend a good 8 to 9 of thick creamy cum, almost making Anthony gag.

As Anthony finished swallowing his boyfriend cum, he came off his cock and slowly started to lift himself up, while kissing Lex’s stomach.

"Fuck babe! That was amazing! But we should clean up and get ready, Henry and Trevor will be here in 10 minutes!" Lex said, smiling and kissing his boyfriend on the lips.

Henry would arrive at their house 20 minutes later, in his Mercedes G class. Stepping out of the car as well, was Trevor, Henry’s boyfriend of almost 7 months. Trevor, was an out and proud NYPD officer, working with the NYPD outreach problem, for the homeless LGBTQIA+ population of the city.

Lex and Anthony loved Trevor, who was of Irish descent and grew up in the Woodlawn section of the Bronx. Standing at 6’1, with reddish blondish hair and a muscular physique. The couple would meet two months after last year's trip. Henry would disappear for two months, after Tommy broke his heart.

Henry thought after that day they first had sex, Tommy would be his and they could start a relationship. However, he was wrong on so many levels. After returning back to the city and Tommy accepting Henry’s father's job, Tommy would reconnect with his high school sweetheart, Melody Ricci. They would soon start a relationship, move in together and a few months ago, found out they were expecting a child.

Henry felt used, betrayed and like a complete asshole. This would result in him taking a two-month sabbatical leave, where he didn’t tell anyone where he was going. Tommy felt defeated and like a fool, to fall for someone that didn’t see him the same way he saw him. However, meeting Trevor was the best thing to ever happen to him. They shared the same interests and now are thinking about taking their relationship to a whole new level, moving in together.

Once on Fire Island, they would meet up with Rodrigo and Timmy. A lot would change for them as well. Rodrigo brought Travis, the guy that tried to get with Tommy last year. The two ended up meeting later that night after Tommy left him and Jacob with blue balls. The two ended up hooking up later that night and have since been dating. Timmy brought his boyfriend, Jason, the muscular black guy who was pounding him at Travis’s pool party. They ended up exchanging numbers and have since been together, even moving in together and recently adopted a shelter dog.

Things were looking great for the friends; they were all in healthy and fanatic relationships. This trip was more about them hanging out and relaxing. They didn’t think about going to the crazy and wild sex parties of Fire Island.

Later that night, as the friends were preparing a great dinner and a board game night with wine, Jacob stopped by to join them, with Lee. Lee would have ended up meeting Jacob later that night as well and they have also been in a relationship. It took some time, but Lee and Anthony ended up patching things up and now are friends.

A few days after, the gang were relaxing, swimming and having fun with each other. Lex asked everyone to meet him on the beach, during the start of the sun descending. As the friends all gathered around, laughing and joking, Anthony saw from the corner of his eye, his brother Tommy, along with now his pregnant girlfriend.

Anthony was confused, as the group all backed up a little and when he turned around, he saw Lex on one knee.

“Anthony Joseph Caruso, from the first moment we met as teenagers, I always knew we were meant to be with one another.
I fell in love with you not knowing what love really was. I stayed in love with you because there’s no one or nothing I’ve ever wanted more than you. I will forever be in love with you because I can’t picture even a second of my life without you.
It might have taken forever for us to be together; this past year has been amazing! I love you so much!
So, Anthony Joseph Caruso, will you marry me?” Lex asked.

As everyone around him was waiting for the answer, he figured out they were all in on this.

“Alexander Michael Rivera. You healed pieces of me I didn’t know needed healing. You cared for me when I didn’t know I could use that extra love. You brought out the happiness in me I didn’t know existed. You’ve made me feel more alive than ever.
Yes, I will marry you Lex!” Anthony said, as he lifted Lex from the sand and their lips locked, as the group around them cheered.

Later on in the night, as the friends were celebrating Lex and Ant’s special night,
Tommy found Henry and pulled him aside.

“Henry, I just wanted to apologize for everything. I was going through a tough time and didn’t know what I wanted. I do truly love you Henry, that night was extremely magical for me. I don’t regret what we did.
However, I did realize, I am not all that attracted to or can be in a relationship with a man.
Like I said, I do truly love you, like a brother, but not like a lover. I truly hope that night doesn’t affect our long-term friendship. I consider you like a brother.” Tommy said, as tears were coming down his face and he embraced Henry.

Henry slowly pushed Tommy away after a minute and spoke.

“Honestly Tommy, you broke my heart, you mentally destroyed me. However, if it wasn’t for that night, I wouldn’t have gone to Ireland and met Trevor. Meeting Trevor has been the best thing for me! I finally understand what true love is and to be in a healthy and happy relationship!
I am not mad at you one bit. I too as well see you as a brother and I love you as well, but in a non-sexual way. Thank you, Tommy, for bringing the love of my life to me.” Henry said, as the two fully embrace one other and tears start coming down their eyes.

As the group of friends and family all embraced each other for this special event, where a year ago, Lex and Anthony first kissed, everything seemed to be going perfectly. However, as we have seen with Tommy, he only thinks of himself, even if it results in hurting others. Tommy looked at Henry with a serious look, as his pants started to twitch. Could this be the last of Tommy messing with Henry’s head? Time will tell.

 

[Anime2]

Thanks for the story I enjoyed the beginning but the near the end it was becoming random and it came across like you decided to change it and go in another direction which is fine but for me it didnt make sense

 

[Radioman1]

I have been fantasizing since this started as to who will play Tommy in the movie. Any recommendations?

 

[gtru1981]

Thanks for the story I enjoyed the beginning but the near the end it was becoming random and it came across like you decided to change it and go in another direction which is fine but for me it didnt make sense

@Anime2 I would love more feedback, where did I loose you? Honestly, after my trip to Europe I developed server writings block on how I wanted this story to go.

The original plan was to have Tommy and Henry and Anthony and Lex being couples. However, during the middle of it, I thought about having Henry confess his love to Anthony and make them the couple at the end.

I think things went the wrong away, when Tommy brought Travis and Jacob into the house after the Jacuzzi thing. I made Tommy too much of a douche in this story, which wasn't suppose to be. Love your feedback, as I might go back and re-write the story down the road.

 

[gtru1981]

I have been fantasizing since this started as to who will play Tommy in the movie. Any recommendations?

When I write the straight guy, I always picture a guy who looks like a mixture of NFL player Danny Amendola and Jimmy Garoppolo and MLB player Joey Gallo. As you can tell, I have a thing for those guys! lol

 

[Simplez]

Hoping n waiting for a new chapter where a dark desire,lusty haunted again between tommy n henry.. showing a temptation between both of them.. Hope u make it continued.. its good story u made.. cheer for u

 

[Di_No]

You did well writing this. It's tough sometimes writing with an audience and posting as the story is being written as opinions can make you question your original plans and direction.

 

[gtru1981]

Hoping n waiting for a new chapter where a dark desire,lusty haunted again between tommy n henry.. showing a temptation between both of them.. Hope u make it continued.. its good story u made.. cheer for u

probably in the new year. I did leave the ending as a continue. Will take some time off from this first.

 

[ndamood4sum]

The Conclusion:
It's been a year since that weekend on Fire Island. Anthony was packing up for this coming 4th of July weekend getaway. A lot has changed over the last year. Ever since that weekend a year ago, he and Lex have been in a wonderful and healthy relationship. A few months after the trip, Anthony’s father, Vincenzo, would have a mild heart attack. This would result in Anthony moving back to Staten Island to be closer to his father, to help around. This gave Lex, now 34 years old, to ask Anthony to move in with him, since his house was a few doors down from his parents.

While Anthony was packing up his stuff for the weekend, Lex would come out of the bathroom.

“Hey babe, turn around, I have something to show you.” Lex said

As Anthony turns around, Lex, completely naked, starts wiggling his body and doing a little dance. Anthony knows the little dance very well; Lex is looking for a quicky. Anthony comes closer and wraps his arms around his boyfriends' hips and pushes him closer to him, where his cock starts to grow.

“Oh Mr. Rivera, looks like something needs some attention!” Anthony whispers seductively in his boyfriend's ear.

As Anthony removed his hand from caressing Lex’s chest, he now put his hands on his bf’s muscular arms and eventually slid them down to where their fingers would intertwine. He slowly guided Lex’s hand, causing their bodies to pull even closer together. Anthony, unlocking his hands, was now guiding them against Lex’s recently trimmed pubes. As both their nipples were now hard and Lex was starting to drip precum, Anthony started to massage Lex’s balls and quickly dropped down to his knees.

Anthony looked up and locked eyes with his boyfriend and slowly licked the tip of his cock, licking the precum off his cock. Lex spread his legs, closed his eyes and tilted his head backwards. Anthony with his left hand, was massaging Lex’s balls, while his right-hand index finger started to tease his hole.

Anthony wrapped his lips around Lex’s cock head and slowly took Lex’s full-length cock into his mouth. Lex let out a moan, as Anthony slowly sucked back and forth. After a few minutes of teasing his boyfriend, he started to deep throat his boyfriend cock.

After about 5 minutes of bobbing back and forth, hearing all the slurping and saliva coming out of Anthony’s mouth, he would let Lex’s cock pop out from his mouth, as he looked up at this boyfriend, while his hand reached below his balls and a finger once again touched his asshole. After licking Lex’s now sweaty stomach, Anthony once again started to deepthroat Lex’s now aching cock and balls, as he made small circles around Lex’s hole with his finger. Lex spread his legs wider, as the sensation was driving him crazy and he was getting close.

Lex was now moaning like crazy, while playing with his hard and sensitive nipples. He didn’t know how much longer he would last. Anthony continued to play with his asshole, with his fingers and continued to deepthroat his cock.

"I am getting close babe!" Lex hissed to his boyfriend, as he could feel the orgasm building and about to explode.

Anthony kept on sucking, faster and faster, as he kept going, bobbing his head back and forth on Lex’s cock. He then inserted his finger into his boyfriend's hole, which resulted in him letting out a very loud moan as he started to explode into Anthony's hungry mouth. Lex could feel his cock feeding his juices into Anthony’s mouth. Lex fed his boyfriend a good 8 to 9 of thick creamy cum, almost making Anthony gag.

As Anthony finished swallowing his boyfriend cum, he came off his cock and slowly started to lift himself up, while kissing Lex’s stomach.

"Fuck babe! That was amazing! But we should clean up and get ready, Henry and Trevor will be here in 10 minutes!" Lex said, smiling and kissing his boyfriend on the lips.

Henry would arrive at their house 20 minutes later, in his Mercedes G class. Stepping out of the car as well, was Trevor, Henry’s boyfriend of almost 7 months. Trevor, was an out and proud NYPD officer, working with the NYPD outreach problem, for the homeless LGBTQIA+ population of the city.

Lex and Anthony loved Trevor, who was of Irish descent and grew up in the Woodlawn section of the Bronx. Standing at 6’1, with reddish blondish hair and a muscular physique. The couple would meet two months after last year's trip. Henry would disappear for two months, after Tommy broke his heart.

Henry thought after that day they first had sex, Tommy would be his and they could start a relationship. However, he was wrong on so many levels. After returning back to the city and Tommy accepting Henry’s father's job, Tommy would reconnect with his high school sweetheart, Melody Ricci. They would soon start a relationship, move in together and a few months ago, found out they were expecting a child.

Henry felt used, betrayed and like a complete asshole. This would result in him taking a two-month sabbatical leave, where he didn’t tell anyone where he was going. Tommy felt defeated and like a fool, to fall for someone that didn’t see him the same way he saw him. However, meeting Trevor was the best thing to ever happen to him. They shared the same interests and now are thinking about taking their relationship to a whole new level, moving in together.

Once on Fire Island, they would meet up with Rodrigo and Timmy. A lot would change for them as well. Rodrigo brought Travis, the guy that tried to get with Tommy last year. The two ended up meeting later that night after Tommy left him and Jacob with blue balls. The two ended up hooking up later that night and have since been dating. Timmy brought his boyfriend, Jason, the muscular black guy who was pounding him at Travis’s pool party. They ended up exchanging numbers and have since been together, even moving in together and recently adopted a shelter dog.

Things were looking great for the friends; they were all in healthy and fanatic relationships. This trip was more about them hanging out and relaxing. They didn’t think about going to the crazy and wild sex parties of Fire Island.

Later that night, as the friends were preparing a great dinner and a board game night with wine, Jacob stopped by to join them, with Lee. Lee would have ended up meeting Jacob later that night as well and they have also been in a relationship. It took some time, but Lee and Anthony ended up patching things up and now are friends.

A few days after, the gang were relaxing, swimming and having fun with each other. Lex asked everyone to meet him on the beach, during the start of the sun descending. As the friends all gathered around, laughing and joking, Anthony saw from the corner of his eye, his brother Tommy, along with now his pregnant girlfriend.

Anthony was confused, as the group all backed up a little and when he turned around, he saw Lex on one knee.

“Anthony Joseph Caruso, from the first moment we met as teenagers, I always knew we were meant to be with one another.
I fell in love with you not knowing what love really was. I stayed in love with you because there’s no one or nothing I’ve ever wanted more than you. I will forever be in love with you because I can’t picture even a second of my life without you.
It might have taken forever for us to be together; this past year has been amazing! I love you so much!
So, Anthony Joseph Caruso, will you marry me?” Lex asked.

As everyone around him was waiting for the answer, he figured out they were all in on this.

“Alexander Michael Rivera. You healed pieces of me I didn’t know needed healing. You cared for me when I didn’t know I could use that extra love. You brought out the happiness in me I didn’t know existed. You’ve made me feel more alive than ever.
Yes, I will marry you Lex!” Anthony said, as he lifted Lex from the sand and their lips locked, as the group around them cheered.

Later on in the night, as the friends were celebrating Lex and Ant’s special night,
Tommy found Henry and pulled him aside.

“Henry, I just wanted to apologize for everything. I was going through a tough time and didn’t know what I wanted. I do truly love you Henry, that night was extremely magical for me. I don’t regret what we did.
However, I did realize, I am not all that attracted to or can be in a relationship with a man.
Like I said, I do truly love you, like a brother, but not like a lover. I truly hope that night doesn’t affect our long-term friendship. I consider you like a brother.” Tommy said, as tears were coming down his face and he embraced Henry.

Henry slowly pushed Tommy away after a minute and spoke.

“Honestly Tommy, you broke my heart, you mentally destroyed me. However, if it wasn’t for that night, I wouldn’t have gone to Ireland and met Trevor. Meeting Trevor has been the best thing for me! I finally understand what true love is and to be in a healthy and happy relationship!
I am not mad at you one bit. I too as well see you as a brother and I love you as well, but in a non-sexual way. Thank you, Tommy, for bringing the love of my life to me.” Henry said, as the two fully embrace one other and tears start coming down their eyes.

As the group of friends and family all embraced each other for this special event, where a year ago, Lex and Anthony first kissed, everything seemed to be going perfectly. However, as we have seen with Tommy, he only thinks of himself, even if it results in hurting others. Tommy looked at Henry with a serious look, as his pants started to twitch. Could this be the last of Tommy messing with Henry’s head? Time will tell.

I also liked most of the beginning, but for me when Tommy started being "friendly" to just about anyone who tried something with him, bothered me. Even after he admitted to feeling some kind of way, he kept on without any regard to Henry or his feelings. I think just about all of them did some questionable things in my opinion, some worst than others and therefore the happily ever after ending shocked me. If nothing else, Tommy and Henry's relationship should have been forever changed. Henry said he felt used, betrayed and like a complete asshole. Why did it take an entire year for Tommy to offer that self serving apology which never acknowledged or apologized for the hurt he actually caused Henry.

I guess Tommy and Lex's friendship was not affected by the public make-out and jerk session, which I found odd that they did not address it with each other or the fact that his long time bestfriend is not dating his brother. The story had been so detailed and left no stone unturned until the end where it felt like it just ended. I thought your original idea of Tommy & Henry and Lex & Anthony being together would have been the good ending while at the same time forgiving Tommy for his behavior on that weekend. But it ended with Tommy being deserving of the Black Sheep of the family title.

 

[Simplez]

probably in the new year. I did leave the ending as a continue. Will take some time off from this first.

Yesss.. you should continues the story cause actually ur story is so good.. its just in my opinion i think toward the ending u kinda rushing to end it.. sorry about what i said.. its just my pov.. but i love ur story.. its include all the emotion in it.. love,lust, family n everything… keep on good work..