Wow, this is a huge list, but here it goes, including my own votes (Cason, Mule, Nick8):
"Topping" the list at 9 votes: Nudeyorker!
Close behind with 7 very dedicated fans: Countryguy63
A tie for third with 6 each: Alphamale, MrSnakey, Mule & Rawdog
And here go the rest of them (so far):
5 votes: Calboner, Drifterwood, Hhuck, hilaire, Luka82 & X704
4 votes: Lex, Nick8, Nubian, Pitbull, SilverTrain, Tripod & Wish-4-8 should feel very honored to be placed in the same group as the late Jason_Els
3 votes: Cason, Daddy_Lucas, DiscoBoy, Exwhysee, forestblahblah, HazelGod, Incubus, Indelicate, invisibleman, Oh_Yeah, Ramsey, Strontium, ThickMeatJacker.
2 votes (and worth mentioning twice): Conchis, Flameboy, Gibson, Goodwood, HungJon, joll, Jason "from politics", MindFawk, omgiswhatdeysay, Pecker, Pendlum, Petergroot, Rowan_Ravenseed, Sbat, silvertriumph2, StraightDave, Tardis69, THEDUDEofDestiny, Vince, xDrDantex, YourAverageGuy, ZOS23xy
And finally, far from the "asshole" list, are the ones who are lucky to be mentioned once in this thread: 8060, Albert_Cunning, Alex22, Alex8, Basque9, Bbucko, Bigcut53, Bigshooter9, BigWad, BillyTheMountain, blkfern, Bort92, bubbahotep1, ccss_oorr, Classyron, CunningStunt, Darkriff, DeeBlackthorne, denton85, DexterMorgan, Dukey, Freddie53, Fursuit, ghb69, Guy-jin, hctib1, hellyeah1138, HickBoy, Ibvettguy, JF, justacynic, Kapahulu, kolic, L_egit, Lacuna22, Landminespring, LargeInLife, LaughingLover, Lemon, mailer, marleyisalegend, MASSIVEPKGO_CHUCK, Matthew, Max1971, Maximiliam, McStang, megvanillazailla, MidLifeBear, Mrblabla, nicenydick, Nottswanker, novice_btm, Patrick28, paul882628, Pieterjoke, Phil_Ayesho, picture_guy, prepstudinsc, Private_45, Qua?, Quercusone, Rawbone, rbkwp, reallyhot, Rico27, Rob_just_Rob, Ronin001, roro82, Roys_Toy, Shawn8, Shocked, SignorFantasco, Sk_bum, SmartCat, Smooth, Social_Joe, SpoLLe, Steve26, Steve319, Stever2550, Strike_4, Stroker_ace, Stu.kay823, STYLYUNG, swiper007, t9knst7, The_Scotsman, TheBoyfriend, Torque_8, tray22nc, VinylBoy, Wellington, Wolf1Bear2, WolfsheimDeutschland.