dong20 said:
We all have our prejudices. For myself when I find myself thinking in a way that could fall along those lines I try to step back, re-evaluate, try find a cause. Sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't but next time I hope I can head it off at the pass. Of course I can't 'know' what it's like to be black/asian or whatever anymore than the other way around.
I have been in situations where I have been the only white face in hundreds or even thousands and I have experienced those things to which you refer. As you know, racism and prejudice, is not an exlusively white phonemenon something which is all to often glossed over, here and elsewhere. Alone I can't fix that, what I can do is listen, learn and try to understand others views as best I can whether I agree with them or not. That's all anyone can do. If we all do it then it may be enough.
Dong, I know you know this wasn't directed at you, I don't see you as a prejudiced person at all. I think part of our perceptual differences, if they exist at all, is the difference in our environments. In the US, race is a big fucking deal. Outside of major cities, it is often the first criteria by which a person will be judged. I don't know if that's true of the UK, I always hope you guys have gotten a few more things sorted out than us n00bs.
Also, I
never meant to infer that it was only white against black. Wherever a majority exists, there are those who will oppress a minority, and it is the same exact wrong! I agree that searching our own hearts for remnants of this behavior is the best way toward progress.
You are right and I'm speaking generally here but surely 'turning the tables' would be a phyrric victory, it may feel good (for a while, maybe) but then no-one will have learned anything. Is black oppression of whites any less wrong?
Righting a wrong requires its eradication not a new owner. Oppression and racism are wrong, period. Racism and oppression in revenge while perhaps understandable would be equally wrong and the whole destructive cycle would simply repeat. I know you are talking about capability not intent but not everyone is so enlightened.
If I said something to lead you to believe I wanted to turn the tables, I apologise for the confusion. Black oppression of whites, particularly in areas where they are the majority is exactly the same thing, and as far as I can tell it happens with pretty much the same frequency. I am not claiming that one race is superior to another or more blameless. I am only saying that nationally, white oppression of blacks is more prevalent, and historically significant. It wasn't Africans who enslaved Euros that we are experiencing a fallout from.
You make a good point about our lack of enlightenment. I agree with you that education is our only hope, and waiting for the really ugly ones to die off.
I've seen that done (both ways) and with the best will in the world the participant (however hard they tell themself otherwise) is 'looking' for bias and is thus more likely to perceive it where it may not actually exist, it's the requirement of the excercise and thus almost by definition renders such exercises 'tabloid entertainment'.
Those behaviours you refer to are not unique to any race or group and I have seen it both ways. If I were a shop owner and someone was acting like a thief you would be safe to assume I would watch them very closely, whatever their skin colour.
No, I completely understand that those things are not unique to one race. What I am saying is that
here and now blacks being marginalised by whites is same shit different day in the majority of places, by the majority of people- therefore I see it as a more immediate problem. In order to correct any imbalance, there is a pendulum swing effect before the pendulum finally finds it's resting place in the middle. It's just time for the pendulum to swing the other way now, as society is forcing that to happen. This is all very normal and in keeping with the history of how human beings accept change.
No doubt there are black shop owners who watch the white punks closely as well. One can also not discount the possibility that a criminal might take special delight from stealing from someone of a race to which he does not belong. Both sides.
I am utterly convinced that I treated her fairly, and with respect as I would anyone else and I believe so did my colleagues. She may have perceived or experienced racism or she may have simply 'played the race card' (Lex's argument nothwithtanding) because it seemed like a sure fire winner. I don't know for sure, only she knows that and she said nothing to indicate such a problem before leaving.
I am utterly convinced that you gave her more than enough leeway. I would have fired her immediately when I discovered she lied on her resume about her knowledge. Now, I never cared if someone lied on their resume about something that didn't matter, like where they went to school or their gpa, but if it affected their ability to perform their job- that's a big problem, I'd have shitcanned her instantly.
She played the race card, flat out. That's bullshit, she was the one who was a liar, and that can be easily proven by her own admission. Inferring that you are a racist because she is incompetant is utter nonsense, and it is that very behavior that leads white people to assume all blacks are freeloading scum.
Actually, the black people who do that are not the majority, but they are the ones who make the news, as it were. I'm sorry you had that experience and I'm glad it didn't lead you to make untrue assumptions about the whole race.
Final question, if Shelby were black (and you drew attention to his colour) would your reaction to his comment been different, and if so why? I'm not trying to be 'clever' I'd genuinely like to know.
I've had the same convo with Dilznick, if that helps anything.