I'm more interested in what exactly you meant by "mixed reviews" by people. Are you talking about in your general sex experiences or from this site?
I'm not really sure how to rate another man, although I have had my personal experiences. Not as clear on your girth, but you appear to be a good average length. Close-ups obscure size and length to me though.
Personally I believe the opinion that should matter the most, is your own. But that's me!