Robert Pattinson

slaterfl

Legendary Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2018
Posts
547
Media
6
Likes
1,570
Points
163
Location
Farmingdale (New York, United States)
I don't know to be honest I feel very few superhero films actually need that R rating to be good. Also most toy manufacturing companies won't make things for film over PG-13 (like lego). And that often times help profits
The batman movies are pretty dark in general, I am actually surprised it isn't R... That being said, completely agree with you that, a less adult rating makes it more inclusive, and might help it reach a bigger audience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jason GayLight

aus1989

Admired Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2015
Posts
282
Media
0
Likes
867
Points
213
Location
Sydney (New South Wales, Australia)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Batman is meant to be dark and gritty
batman however is not generally violent or graphic sexually etc... to be dark, Matt Reeves' Planet Of The Apes movies as two examples of dark, gritty PG-13 movies (and Batman has also been everything from Adam West to edgelord Frank Miller so... it's not really meant to be anything specifically)
 
  • Like
Reactions: slaterfl

Lover man

Worshipped Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2017
Posts
17,086
Media
0
Likes
24,869
Points
158
Sexuality
Unsure
Gender
Male
batman however is not generally violent or graphic sexually etc... to be dark, Matt Reeves' Planet Of The Apes movies as two examples of dark, gritty PG-13 movies (and Batman has also been everything from Adam West to edgelord Frank Miller so... it's not really meant to be anything specifically)
That is certainly true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Empirerec

Empirerec

Legendary Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2020
Posts
468
Media
0
Likes
2,223
Points
188
Location
Christchurch (Canterbury, New Zealand)
Sexuality
90% Gay, 10% Straight
Gender
Male
I don't see any benefit in an R rated batman, it works for Joker but Batman is well a lot of kids wanna see this movie, an R rated batman would just be a few swear words and maybe some tits and hyper violence, we've got the punisher for that, you can be dark and gritty and still pg13
 

JayCeeC

Sexy Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2021
Posts
44
Media
0
Likes
96
Points
28
Location
Miami (Florida, United States)
Sexuality
Pansexual
Gender
Male
I don't see any benefit in an R rated batman, it works for Joker but Batman is well a lot of kids wanna see this movie, an R rated batman would just be a few swear words and maybe some tits and hyper violence, we've got the punisher for that, you can be dark and gritty and still pg13
That’s not the target audience for this movie though. DC’s pitfall in the past has been to tone down movies for the PG-13 rating to make it accessible to a broader audience, and it ends up being that their key demo are from millennials backwards, all of which are now grown adults who like their DC movies to be as dark and grown up as they’ve come to expect from this cinematic universe. Kids these days are not as interested in this type of movie as those who grew up with the other Batmans. And if they are, they’ll still go watch it regardless of the rating. That doesn’t mean as much as it used to in the past. And if we weren’t as puritanical as we are, we would’ve updated our rating system like most of Europe has and not be clutching pearls over some swear words and mild nudity.
 

eas12397

Admired Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2021
Posts
493
Media
0
Likes
780
Points
113
Location
Arizona (United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Zack snyder's justice league was better not because of it's rating but because the storyline cohesive and that last director was prick and they wanted marvel humor.

Birds of prey bombed in theaters and failed to build everyone except Harley Quinn.

The suicide squad needed the violence (because that's what it's known for). But even then people were upset with some of characters death's being to early

Shazam and WW both well received PG-13 films

Joker- wasn't really inspired by dc comics (taking main inspiration from Taxi Driver). Nor is it supposed to work with In the DCEU (which is what they said about The Batman as well)

B v S extended cut still sucked and is only really known for the martha scene

Aquman was decent only bad thing was Amber Heards acting (but still did good for a pg-13 film)

Suicide Sqaud was a failed mess with behind the scenes drama.

But The Dark Knight still considered one of their best if not DC film. People were pissed it didn't get an Oscar nomination for best picture. The academy changed how many films could be nominated a given year because of their outrage (a pg-13 film)

Truth is DC issues aren't ratings it's because they rushed to try and have what MCU had, and they tried to emulate it in some ways and didn't work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: undyinghangman

Depressedkarevik

Superior Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2021
Posts
1,517
Media
0
Likes
9,712
Points
333
Location
Sweden
Sexuality
No Response
Zack snyder's justice league was better not because of it's rating but because the storyline cohesive and that last director was prick and they wanted marvel humor.

Birds of prey bombed in theaters and failed to build everyone except Harley Quinn.

The suicide squad needed the violence (because that's what it's known for). But even then people were upset with some of characters death's being to early

Shazam and WW both well received PG-13 films

Joker- wasn't really inspired by dc comics (taking main inspiration from Taxi Driver). Nor is it supposed to work with In the DCEU (which is what they said about The Batman as well)

B v S extended cut still sucked and is only really known for the martha scene

Aquman was decent only bad thing was Amber Heards acting (but still did good for a pg-13 film)

Suicide Sqaud was a failed mess with behind the scenes drama.

But The Dark Knight still considered one of their best if not DC film. People were pissed it didn't get an Oscar nomination for best picture. The academy changed how many films could be nominated a given year because of their outrage (a pg-13 film)

Truth is DC issues aren't ratings it's because they rushed to try and have what MCU had, and they tried to emulate it in some ways and didn't work.
WTF, Suicide Squad is gooooood! And James Gunn is doing an AMAZING job in the Peacemaker series.
Justice League was bad in both cuts.
 

eas12397

Admired Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2021
Posts
493
Media
0
Likes
780
Points
113
Location
Arizona (United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
WTF, Suicide Squad is gooooood! And James Gunn is doing an AMAZING job in the Peacemaker series.
Justice League was bad in both cuts.
I didn't say suicide squad was bad. The only issue is that they killed off to many at the beginning, rather spread it out (special with a character like boomerang) could of killed some of it for parts middle act you know? As for Snyder's Justice league it's still better then the one that went theaters. (I don't care to see the snyderverse back)
 

Empirerec

Legendary Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2020
Posts
468
Media
0
Likes
2,223
Points
188
Location
Christchurch (Canterbury, New Zealand)
Sexuality
90% Gay, 10% Straight
Gender
Male
The dark knight isn't considered one of the best DC movies or best superhero movies it's considered one of the best movies of all time.

I think this movie is going to be awesome with the potential to out do the dark knight story wise. I don't think for WBs biggest property an R rated movie makes sense unless it's something that's crucial to the plot that censors won't allow , then they should stand their ground.

Kids are wanting to see this movie whether it's marketed to then or not though.

I liked Harley Quinn but it didn't need an R rating you could take out the coke scene and the swears and it'd be the same film. Suicide Squad 2021 was exactly what a suicide squad movie should be, Aquaman and Shazam were fun, wonder woman 1984 was meh ww was pretty damn good.

Snyder's justice league was good in comparison to the Frankenstein 2017 film but it's still a pretty average justice league story.

I'm really happy this Batman has no connection to that mess of a universe that was a mess from the beginning.
 

JayCeeC

Sexy Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2021
Posts
44
Media
0
Likes
96
Points
28
Location
Miami (Florida, United States)
Sexuality
Pansexual
Gender
Male
The dark knight isn't considered one of the best DC movies or best superhero movies it's considered one of the best movies of all time.

I think this movie is going to be awesome with the potential to out do the dark knight story wise. I don't think for WBs biggest property an R rated movie makes sense unless it's something that's crucial to the plot that censors won't allow , then they should stand their ground.

Kids are wanting to see this movie whether it's marketed to then or not though.

I liked Harley Quinn but it didn't need an R rating you could take out the coke scene and the swears and it'd be the same film. Suicide Squad 2021 was exactly what a suicide squad movie should be, Aquaman and Shazam were fun, wonder woman 1984 was meh ww was pretty damn good.

Snyder's justice league was good in comparison to the Frankenstein 2017 film but it's still a pretty average justice league story.

I'm really happy this Batman has no connection to that mess of a universe that was a mess from the beginning.
Plenty of directors, particularly of this genre, have said in the past that rating places constraints on the story and creative process as to what can and cannot be part of the story. Like I said, the kids who want to see this movie won’t be stopped by its rating. And if they are too young, then this movie or anything with extreme violence is not for them anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: undyinghangman

mikyang

Superior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2021
Posts
4,081
Media
0
Likes
7,001
Points
158
Location
Rockville (Maryland, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Zack snyder's justice league was better not because of it's rating but because the storyline cohesive and that last director was prick and they wanted marvel humor.

Birds of prey bombed in theaters and failed to build everyone except Harley Quinn.

The suicide squad needed the violence (because that's what it's known for). But even then people were upset with some of characters death's being to early

Shazam and WW both well received PG-13 films

Joker- wasn't really inspired by dc comics (taking main inspiration from Taxi Driver). Nor is it supposed to work with In the DCEU (which is what they said about The Batman as well)

B v S extended cut still sucked and is only really known for the martha scene

Aquman was decent only bad thing was Amber Heards acting (but still did good for a pg-13 film)

Suicide Sqaud was a failed mess with behind the scenes drama.

But The Dark Knight still considered one of their best if not DC film. People were pissed it didn't get an Oscar nomination for best picture. The academy changed how many films could be nominated a given year because of their outrage (a pg-13 film)

Truth is DC issues aren't ratings it's because they rushed to try and have what MCU had, and they tried to emulate it in some ways and didn't work.
I think birds of prey bombed since it was too zany and too cartoony
 
  • Like
Reactions: undyinghangman