I ran across your question earlier today and wanted to think about it for awhile. I am wondering why some of the more dedicated members haven't responded yet?
I am new to LPSG.org and though I have posted a few items, I am still trying to test the waters. I hope you find my response helpful. Here it goes...
I dont think it is a matter of either/or. It is both. Unfortunately, for people in todays society, pornography has propagated a one-size-fits-all ideology. However, historical documentation, especially in the Chinese and Indian cultures, discusses the importance of certain sized men being accommodated by certain types of women. Despite the euphemisms within the Kama Sutra and the sexual disciplines of Taoism, the right fit seems to be critical in order for the participants to fully experience what these handbooks were designed to enhance.
Personally, I have never had the opportunity to explore the size issue, as I have always chosen partners for their personality and sense of humor first. And none of my lovers has been endowed in the dimensions that seem to predominate this group. As I have never been the kind of girl that asks for a bank balance or penis size before I say yes, penis size has always fallen secondary to my actual attraction to the person and their skill at foreplay.
However, for the sake of this discussion you should know that the best lover and the worst lover I ever had were also the two smallest penises in my experience. The biggest penis Ive had would possibly fit into the lower size category of this group. Im not certain I could truly enjoy carnal knowledge with someone whos packing because I would find the size daunting. But that doesnt mean I wouldnt give it a go. For women, stimulation before sex is both physical and psychological. If I knew my lover was hung like some of you are, he would have to overcome and exploit the combination of surprise, fear, fascination, challenge, determination, and curiosity I would feel. Hed also have to discover my physical hot buttons (which Im not telling) that get me wet, wet, wet.
For the record, I have been in a committed relationship for several years and am very happy. This means that fortunately (or perhaps unfortunately) I will probably never have the chance to act on my fascination with a large, beautifully proportioned penis. Oh well, I guess that is what fantasy is for sigh!
It doesnt really matter anyway because my main desire from this group is to get straight answers to questions that no one else, either in person or online, seems inclined to respond to honestly. As a researcher, I know that knowledge cannot always be found in the library or between the pages. Sometimes, you need to learn it from the street. I am greatful to have found you all.