size that makes you go yum or yikes

fournineteenfiftynine

Legendary Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Posts
1,470
Media
10
Likes
1,758
Points
593
Location
Minneapolis (Minnesota, United States)
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
The first time with a guy and he unveils the goods...what's your reaction to certain sizes?

I'll go first: these are actually reactions Ive had

5 inches - if nicely shaped on a guy with a cute body I went "yum"
6 inches - nice!
6.5 inches and thick - really really nice
7 inches - I won the lottery
7.5 inches - I won a better lottery
8 inches - ooh...would like to play with that...not sure I want it up my ass but could play with that all night
9 inches - yikes...oh god I wish I could take it and maybe would like to try but oh love to play with it
10 inches - wow that is like amazing.....what's it like having a monster like that?