I hooked up with a NFL player four times in summer 2018, and have been hooking up with another NFL player from a different team off and on since October 2021. Can't say either of their names due to NDAA agreements, but I can say that they are both starters for their teams and the team of the player from 2018 made it to the Super Bowl this year.
Sex with both of them was/is great, but not particularly mind-blowing. The player from 2018 was sweet and passionate. He loved missionary, and always stared into my eyes and kissed when we had sex...how romantic lol. Physically, he's huge so when he'd be on top of me, it felt like he was shielding me from the world and I loved that. He said I was the first guy he'd ever been with (which I believe) and he received his first ever rimjob from me, which he said afterward he didn't like at all but at least he was a trooper and let me have my fun in between his big, hairy ass cheeks lol. He was incredibly sweet and we kept in touch all summer long and he even offered me game tickets for the games he played in my city. Unfortunately it fizzled out due to our respective schedules. Haven't talked to him since that summer, but still have his phone number.
The player I'm with now is almost the polar opposite: 100% stereotypical jock-alpha-meathead. VERY arrogant out in public. He's fun to be around but it's also draining, especially because I'm an introvert. But one-on-one he's a complete gentleman and always wants to make sure I'm comfortable. I've spent the night at his place 5 times since we first met, and he always asks if I have food/snack requests so he can grab it before I arrive. We've done "bro dates" at restaurants several times, and he's even taken me shopping lol. He texts at least once a week with "What's up boiiiii" or "Thinking about you kid", even though I'm 8 years older than him lol.
I'm not in the mental gymnastics business of trying to label people's sexuality, because at the end of the day I don't care. I know I'm not gonna marry this guy; we're both just having fun for the time being. Both of them are very unassuming and guys you would never even remotely guess to have sex with men. I've asked the current player if he sleeps around with other guys and he said no, I'm the only one, but he did tell me that he sleeps around a lot with other girls (which I already suspected).