Sorry, I have been a lurker on these forums for a long time, I guess I didn't feel connected to the community until now.
FSU - I read your story and had flash backs to when I joined manhunt 7 years ago. I feel for you, it can be tough and confusing on MH.
Sorry for the long winded post, as you can tell you got some memories/emotions stirred up. I didn't realize I had written a book until I tried to proof read it.
I live in Massachusetts and joined Manhunt to check out the "gay scene". I knew I was gay since I was 16 but it wasn't until I was 30 that I stopped dating women and finally was ok with just being myself and stopped pretending.
Anyways after a couple weeks of Manhunt. I met someone and we exchanged emails for about a month, I felt like I really knew the guy. He understood that I hadn't dated a guy before and that I wasn't looking to "hook-up". We talked on the phone a couple times and I got to know him better and finally we got together to have dinner.
It was exciting, I wanted everything to be just right, my clothes, hair,etc. We went to an Italian place in Boston, he was handsome and friendly and I really liked him. After dinner we had a couple beers and walked around the city for a while just talking it was great, I felt really connected to him. We had been together for three hours and he said he didn't want the date to end and asked me back to his place to relax and talk more, I was psyched.
Back at his apartment we sat on the couch and talked, laughed and for a while. He sheepishly asked if he could kiss me, of course I said yes and after making out for a few minutes things escalated and soon our pants on the floor and he was blowing me while he jerked off. I tried to kiss him and jerk him but he would twist away and playfully push me back and go back to blowing me again. After a while he had cum and finished me off as well, my head was spinning from all the beer and I was psyched that things turned out so well.
He excused himself and went to the bathroom to clean up and I got dressed, when he came back he walked me to the door and said goodnight. We hugged and he just held me in his arms for a couple minute, kissed me good night and thanked me for coming over and seemed honestly excited to see me again, we made vague plans to get together the following weekend and I walked back to my car in a happy daze.
Sadly things turned sour pretty quick. The next day I emailed him to firm up our plans and he didn't reply, it was weird I was sure he was online and wondered how he could have missed my email. The next day I sent a second email and got no reply, then I checked the Manhunt "Sent" option and saw he had read both the emails earlier but never replied, It sucked, it felt like I got sucker punched.
I didn't know what the heck happened, I got the courage to call his cell and left a message and the next day another but He didn't return my calls, it fucked me up. I replayed the date in my head a hundred times trying to figure out what I did wrong, did I say something, did I do something, maybe I wasn't good looking enough ? Nothing made any sense. I was kinda depressed and hurt by the whole thing and it took me a couple weeks before I stopped obsessing and started to slowly get over it.
About a month later I ran into him at a local Gay bar, he was standing with a group of guys and I walked by. I caught his eyes and nodded "hi", he just looked away and kept chatting with his friends. I walked by a couple more time through out the night trying to catch him alone but it never happened. I wanted to him to say something, tell what happened by he wouldn't even look at me. It was such a shitty feeling, It made me question whether I could even date guys...
Over the last few years I have met alot of guys and dated a than a few, I learned that for me guys are really complex, alot more complex than my previous girlfriends. I discovered that dealing with being gay can be hard for some guys and they develop emotional tricks / scars to deal with their feelings. Instead of the out right denial I went through in my 20's
Some guys only want anonymous sex, some even build weird plywood walls with holes cut out and invite guys over for a blow job but can't look them in the face.
Some guys acts all innocent and naive and pretend they have never dated guys before until they get you to have sex and afterwards they throw you away like some weird sexual conquest. They have slept with tons of guys but never more than once and pretend they are virgins.
Some guys have crazy hang ups and the imagine that you are the guy for them but after meeting or kissing,etc. They decided you are not and in mid kiss can push you away and ask you to leave, claiming their isn't any Chemistry.
Other people's drama and problems are not your fault. Just try to be yourself and don't get jaded if things don't work out sometimes. Even though I had had my share of bad dates / hookups I stayed with it. I know what I want and I stayed on Manhunt and learned to be a little more reserved and careful with how fast I fell for a guy. I have met a bunch of great guys on Manhunt, in spite of the losers...
Guys that I became close friends for the last 6+ years.
Guys I dated for a few great months before we realized were weren't looking for the same thing.
A Guy I loved and dated for 4 years until his work and our relationship became too much to juggle, we are still friends but not together anymore.
And just a few weeks ago I met someone that reminds me of me when I first joined Manhunt. He is sweet, naive to a fault and sexy as hell but doesn't realize it. After our 3rd date we decided to be exclusive and see where things go so two weeks ago I updated my Manhunt profile, proudly explaining I had found someone special and cancelled my account.
It is tough to be the new kid on the block and Manhunt comes along with some painful lessons but don't be discouraged there are good people out there. Don't let the bad ones scare you away.
-Mark...