IMHO when he was performing "I'm On a Roll" completely solo, he sucked. When he was singing with back-up...sounded fairly good--and he is a good-looking guy. (The studio version prolly sounds great.) Really don't know him as a performer, however, since I didn't watch any of last year's AI and this was the first and only AI show I've seen this season, although I have been keeping an eye on Phillip's progress. (Sorry, but Steven Tyler absolutely creeps me out.) Sexy Adam Levine has kept me solely devoted to The Voice this year...and I only have patience to follow one performance-based reality show at a time--so no DWTS either.