Surprised by Size

needtonut

Legendary Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Nov 19, 2007
Posts
314
Media
6
Likes
1,381
Points
498
Location
Dallas (Texas, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
Have any of you ever been surprised by the size of another guy's penis? Either it was much bigger or much smaller than you thought it would be. This can be in a casual situation such as changing in a locker room or maybe a guy you were getting ready to fool around with for the first time.

Share all the details!

There was a guy I knew casually through friends. He was a beefy muscled out guy. Probably 6'5" with broad shoulders, big arms and chest. Big strong hands and bigger shoes than my sized 10. Anyhow, one day I'm at the gym and head to the locker room after a work out. I look up and see this guy coming out of the showers with the towel over his shoulder. He's hanging about 2 inches and it's not thick at all. Granted he was soft so hopefully he's a major grower. A few months later a group of us were hanging out drinking beer. After several rounds the conversation turned to sex and this guy admits to everyone that he isn't very hung. I could have verified but I just took another drink instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Organoeda

baldyboy8000

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Posts
698
Media
0
Likes
192
Points
63
Sexuality
No Response
Sitting in the hot tub, I saw a very thin, about 5'7". I left the tub, went to sauna. In a few this guy came in the sauna...the longest, thickest I had ever seen. Another is 6'7", size 16 shoe and he has a micro-penis. go figure
 

Musclehung

Cherished Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
Posts
317
Media
0
Likes
261
Points
78
Location
New York City (New York, United States)
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
Funny to see this topic come up . Tonight hooked up w a dude at gym. Big musld dude and i have found that usually means small manhood. This dude was thick as hell and had major nuts. A nice surprise. Just got home from his place and will sleep well tonight!
 

Silvertip

Worshipped Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Aug 22, 2007
Posts
7,419
Media
473
Likes
15,079
Points
468
Location
Alamosa (Colorado, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
Unsure
Gender
Male
I've had two such surprises. First was a guy up in Denver that I met online and invited him over to my hotel room on one of my stays in the city. He hadn't bragged about his dick size or anything and didn't have any pictures to share so I didn't know what to think. When he doffed his clothes I saw that his cock was only about two inches long, flaccid, but with decent girth. Girth is most important to me so I wasn't disappointed. We hit the bed in a 69 and as I sucked him he just kept growing and growing. Fully erect it was about the same size as my own cock and, yes, I was very surprised ... and pleased.

The second was a totally straight encounter. It was a relatively small guy (I'm guessing about 5'8") who I had met before but on this occasion we were in a group of guys on a fishing trip. At one point the beer got to him and he pulled his dick out to take a leak. I couldn't get a real sense of how long his dick was but it certainly featured one of the biggest, most beautiful glans I had ever laid eyes upon. And not in an extreme mushroom fashion either, the shaft immediately behind his glans was of proportional thickness. To my slight embarrassment, at the time, I just couldn't take my eyes off it. That was before I started playing with guys, today I wouldn't be embarrassed at all to just openly ogle that beautiful sight. That was a long time ago, but I still get hard just thinking about that beautiful vision.
 

B_Lightkeeper

Loved Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2006
Posts
5,268
Media
0
Likes
668
Points
208
Location
Eastern Alabama
Sexuality
99% Gay, 1% Straight
Gender
Male
Years ago (when those Spandex pants were popular) a customer came in my store wearing only them and and a shirt. I thought they were mainly for workout or jogging but he wore them as everyday wear. I couldn't get over the size he showed of a big cut cock. Later on I got him in the back room watching XXX DVDs and certainly was not disappointed. It was even bigger on hard. Oh, what memories!
 

catman

Cherished Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2004
Posts
2,413
Media
0
Likes
364
Points
208
Location
Ga
Sexuality
50% Straight, 50% Gay
Gender
Male
Same here- big beefy, straight, handsome guy at the gym, covered in fur (and sweat) showing a nice package and wears a jockstrap (nice to see) ...finally caught him coming out of the shower...and wanted to weep. ALL balls, nothing else there (a 'nub').

Explains all the working out? But this guy was fantasy material....even catching a whiff of him was a turn on...

the flip side is the nice older schleppy guy, wears polyester pants, boxers, bad tie, covered in fur front and back, wedding ring, has kids (I have heard him chatting), and hung like a mule. (there is an odd 'flap' in front that I assumed was lower belly or...just never in a million years would have guessed *that*. wow.
 

Westley

Sexy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2011
Posts
97
Media
10
Likes
30
Points
53
Location
horseshoe beach florida
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
yes when i was 16 my first uncut cock i suck was 11inch and hes 15 and the time his cum tasted so sweet i tried to catch up with him last year and he wouldnt have anything to do with but i cant help but wonder how big it is now!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SouthHarrow

Westley

Sexy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2011
Posts
97
Media
10
Likes
30
Points
53
Location
horseshoe beach florida
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
And in my area there is these small skinny young skater looking guys but there Hung like horse's i dont get it then the chubbys have small ones the tall guys here are hit or miss!
 
8

842806

Guest
Well i must say my first bf realy supprised me for beign so big.
Hurted a bit at the start, but that goes over quite fast


Have any of you ever been surprised by the size of another guy's penis? Either it was much bigger or much smaller than you thought it would be. This can be in a casual situation such as changing in a locker room or maybe a guy you were getting ready to fool around with for the first time.

Share all the details!

There was a guy I knew casually through friends. He was a beefy muscled out guy. Probably 6'5" with broad shoulders, big arms and chest. Big strong hands and bigger shoes than my sized 10. Anyhow, one day I'm at the gym and head to the locker room after a work out. I look up and see this guy coming out of the showers with the towel over his shoulder. He's hanging about 2 inches and it's not thick at all. Granted he was soft so hopefully he's a major grower. A few months later a group of us were hanging out drinking beer. After several rounds the conversation turned to sex and this guy admits to everyone that he isn't very hung. I could have verified but I just took another drink instead.
 

edonline

LPSG Legend
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Posts
18,879
Media
23
Likes
170,807
Points
543
Location
United States
Sexuality
90% Gay, 10% Straight
Gender
Male
A few years ago, I worked with a "short person" and we got along well. I had never thought about his size until one day I found myself in the gym with him as we were getting undressed in the locker room and saw that he was well hung, even by the standard of a normal height guy. I must have looked longer than I should have because he laughed a little and said "Don't worry about, most guys are surprised. They must expect me to have a teeny weenie". He later told me that he a girlfriend - a normal height young red head - who he said was "very satisfied".
 

CUBE

Superior Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
May 28, 2005
Posts
8,542
Media
13
Likes
7,667
Points
433
Location
The OC
Verification
View
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
Have stated this here before I guess. Best buddy for years always came off like a big cocked guy. He was very sexual and though straight he had some curious times. We get to the point of changing for a swim and things are heating up. He feels me up and he is just like, "dam, so big" Then I see his erection and it is on the small side for sure. I could care less as he is a powerful man in general. I compliemted him and tried to be cool. It totally changed things between us. He never said anything but he hated me being bigger. He talked about my size and never talked about his anymore. He drifted soon afetr and I think is the reason.