Ha Ha I think it is one we will have to agree to disagree, but thank you for a good intelligent conversation, I certainly am not a snowbird, as I say I lived in the USA for 10 years and all my travel to the USA is for business., all in all ( I am older) I have spent a lot of my life travelling and have traveled to over 70 countries so I have experienced the good and bad of many countries.
As for realizing how uptight some countries are, yes I do know and do agree, I have traveled extensively, lived in 5 different countries and at the moment have bases in 2 countries that are very different and worlds apart in thinking and distance.
When you say
“Nonetheless, people in Montréal are not so much like people in Vancouver as to be indistinguishable and just generally Canadian.” They are very different, do not forget you have 3 different cultures as there are the Canadian and the Quebecois ( I say this as you were talking about Montreal) even though the word Quebecois does refer to anyone from the Qubec region it is normally applied to the French speaking and they would not be very happy if they were classed as just Canadians, there are still quite a few people in the region that do not even speak English, one of my best friends mothers only speaks French and lives quite a different life, and does have quite a different culture, then you have the First Nations people which is a large group in Canada there are over 600 First Nation Governments in Canada, they again are very different culturally and would not like to be classified as Canadians, They are First Nations people and their culture spreads over thousands of years.
You mention that “
As an aside, Canada is not a large country. The land itself is more vast than the US, but nearly all of it is empty’ do not forget that the USA is not very dense in population, it is not 100% correct but England can fit into Texas nearly 5 times, therefore if the USA had the same density of population as England the USA would have all its just over 300million people living in Texas, in fact the USA is a very lowly populated country compared to most but yes Canada has a very low population density.
You say about how I have used the words society and culture, yes you are correct I have interlaced them with the incorrect meaning at times but I do honestly believe that society and culture are repressed in the USA, as an example I am in Europe at the moment and last night ( I must admit it was terrible) there was a TV program on mainstream TV that was a dating program but the person picked on body looks ! Something I disagree with but women would see 6 men from the neck down totally naked and the TV would show everything, the person with the host would discuss openly penis size, shape etc and then a man would be put in the same position choosing a woman (terrible TV, but apparently shown in a lot of countries in Europe) but it is on openly on a mainstream channel, other things that are shown very openly are gay programs, advertisements for sex toys and many other things, I believe that a lot of these things would not be acceptable in the USA by the mass of society or culture, please do not get me wrong I know there are people and I am sure most here would not mind but it is not the mass.
I also agree with you on living in large multi-cultural high density cities I have also done that and yes there is a difference between people and their attitudes but it will depend on the mass of the people which will sometime dictate culture, i.e. if a TV program was put on and the mass of people were to disapprove because of their culture and / or beliefs then society would find it inappropriate.
One part that you say :-
When you visited Las Vegas, did it not occur to you even then, standing in the city built by outlaws, the place that turned the desert into a gold mine, a Mecca for partying, that Vegas too is part of American culture? A place where repressed people can blow off steam, sure, but also a place where the more free can explore themselves.
I do disagree with, Las Vegas was not built by outlaws, anything but actually, it was founded by people finding a route to Las Angeles it was originally a green lush valley inhabited by Indians and it became what is known as part of the Old Spanish Trail and the first main migration was of Mormons who cultivated the land and were farmers.
Yes, it is a Mecca for partying and yes it is part of American culture but one thing not to forget that apart from American Indians USA culture is still very young when compared to other places, an example is where I am at the moment has been populated since the 6th Century and there has been a town since the 14th Century, perhaps that is why one of the oldest professions is legal here LOL Although Nevada does have some (but very little legal prostitution, very few brothels and all in out of the way areas) in a lot of areas such as Las Vegas it is illegal, I am not someone that agrees or disagrees with prostitution but again why is it illegal in as you say a party city ? Most things that can be done in Vegas can be done in any European capitol and perhaps more, as I mentioned before, live sex shows, prostitution etc etc, not saying things like this are good but they are allowed.
In my last trip to Las Vegas I was there for 3 months the trip before for 2 months all in all over a period of many years I have spent over 2 years in Las Vegas, in fact it is where my companies are based ( no they are not in the sex industry LOL) in Las Vegas it is a fun place and a good party place, but it is no more liberal than many many cities all over the world for freedom of what you can do in fact you can do less than some cities.
One thing I will say is that I really do love the USA, I like the people and I like the country, but perhaps it is a personal thing I feel as if people can do more in other places and actually have a bit more freedom to do as they choose, I do not say that is always good!
All I can do is give my view after living in the USA and other countries that I have visited or lived in, and everyone is welcome to their view, that is what makes us individuals.
If you look up articles about the subject of Sexual Repression in the USA it is widely written about, a couple of fun articles are :-
http://www.alternet.org/story/15497..._makes_america_a_less_healthy_and_happy_place
And
http://www.martyklein.com/censorship-and-the-fear-of-sexuality/