After seeing all the hipster chicks here in Tucson, I have to say that it's become a turnoff. I can't be a hypocrite because I have a couple myself, but they're on my shoulder blades and so they're not visible most of the time. I can admire some neat, intricately done small artwork. But if a chick is rocking a sleeve or a bunch of them trying them cover a full body part, the only thing I can think is, How the hell are you gonna get a job looking like that?
And since I'm trying to be a professor... well... Eh.
So, nope; they're a turnoff to me.