Mine had to be upwards of 10 inches...yes really...and I always wondered if it might be a birth defect. It was about 3.5-4 inches ACROSS, and about 8.5 long. It looked like a torta (Mexican sandwich - though the guy was lily white). He always claimed to be embarrassed about it, though he was offered a LOT of money (mid-5 figures) to do porn, even if he covered his face. I made a valiant attempt to suck it a few times (apparently I did better than anyone in his life!) and did manage to get it into my ass a couple of times, albeit not to the base...