OK, since no one else said it, I'll say it:
The Blair Witch Project. OK, OK, the movie got a lot of hype and was followed by a bad sequel, but it was scary as hell. Although I can't exactly say that I enjoyed the film--I was one of the many people who got motion sickness from watching it--it certainly was effective. When the movie ended, I left feeling like I had just be trapped in the woods for a week, lost, hungry, sick, terrified, and being stalked by...something. Even though I knew it was a work on fiction, not the documentary it pretended to be, I left believing that there are far more dangerous and sinister things lurking in the woods than bears and wolves; I reconnected with that instinctive knowledge we all have (but learn to suppress) that there's
evil in the darkness--personified, supernatural evil, just like every child knows that there are mosters in the closet, and under the bed, and in the cracks of the sofa...there are horrible things out there, and they're coming to get you.
In other words, this movie brilliantly taps into our primeval fear of the unknown, and turns our own imaginations against us.
I left the theater afraid to go out into the darkness of parking lot, afraid to look towards the woods on the other side of the parking lot. When my friends and I got home, we turned all the lights on in the house, and gathered together in the living room together for comfort. I made hot chocolate for everyone, but I was so shook up I had trouble forcing myself to leave their company to go to the kitchen by myself, and I stayed as far from the window as possible. (The kitchen had a big window with no blinds or curtains, so I was exposed to the darkness outside.) After drinking our cocoa our friends had the courage to go home, and my housemates went to bed. My bedroom was in the basement...the far side of the basement...and I would have to walk past two dark and empty storage rooms to get to my bedroom. I ended up falling asleep on the sofa. I woke up a short time later, and in my groggy state was able to stumble downstairs to bed, but if I had woken up fully I would have been to scared to go.
Horror Movie Review of The Blair Witch Project - Big scares, little budget.
I love the 1982 version of
The Thing. I saw it again recently and it's still good.
Back in college I saw a movie called
Prince of Darkness, which at the time I thought was pretty scary. I saw part of it again a few years ago, and it seemed cheesy.
Jacob's Ladder kept me guessing about what the hell was going on. First I questioned the main character's sanity, then I began questioning my own.
The clown in
IT was pretty scary. The stupid spider-creature at the end, not so much. But what really made the movie scary was seeing all these adults genuinely terrified of a childhood monster when they realized It was back and that they would have to face it again.
I'll have to rent
Black Christmas.
Has anyone seen
Duel? I've heard good things about it, but I haven't seen it yet myself.
Bloodletters - Top 50 Horror Movies
The 100 Greatest Horror Movies from BHM, Updated and Expanded for 2008!
P.S. I've been hearing...things...moving outside my window all night. They're probably just normal nighttime noises that I'd normally tune out, so I'm trying to ignore them (also, I'm afraid to look).