First there is no way possible I can top Mr Ed's well thought out answer. Kuddos
@Mr Ed in Mass
I think there are several different answers for people based on their moods. I don't think there is a right answer based on your sexual preferences.
It starts with the female and the scenario for straight porn with me.
In general I am attracted to the Asian women in porn. Having said that I think the JAV stuff has some beautiful women, but its done fucking abysmally. If they shot Mandingo, Lex Steele and Danny D they would all look like they had a dick my size. They also make the women scream like banshees before the guy even has his little pecker out, let alone penetrating. For all of the Asian guys that are constantly screaming about the "why is it all people think we have small dicks" syndrome, the buck stops there. I take your word for it, now tell them dudes to use better camera angles.
For the big dick loving guys here, how do you feel about watching Ron Jeremy make a come back? The guy has a piece of beef that would frighten small farm animals, but he has let his health and body go to shit, so I don't think its all about the big cock.
I don't mind seeing a guy with a cock my size, bigger or smaller as long as he isn't an out of shape dickhead, that acts like a fucking nimrod.
Stuff that I like (in no order or priority):
a) Asians (exotic women or all color, dark haired women, brunettes, reds and then the over played blondes)
b) MILFS
c) Amateurs
d) Gangbangs under 5 males, one female
e) Interracial
f) Asian MILF amateurs getting gangbanged
g) Big pussy lips
h) natural tits
i) nylons and garters (yes I am an old fashioned perv)
k) swingers, partner swapping, or adults having consensual fun
I can tell you more about what I hate about porn now than what I like, so here goes:
1) guys that have to jerk off on the chicks face, while she stares at him mouth agape
2) Excessive asshole fucking. Anal is insanely out of control. You like pussy but you want to watch an hour and a half of non-stop butt fucking?
3) stupid interviewing assholes that say "so whats the biggest dick you have seen/fucked/sucked/etc" and the asinine females that show their fingers six inches apart after they just finished a shoot with Danny D and Mandingo
4) Assholes that choke the female or step on the girls head
5) Cuckold porn with the same four male actors, they are like tag team wrestlers
6) Schoolgirl or dubious age play shit
7) Actors/actresses with bad tit or cock jobs (yes they exist)
8) Anything where the guy jerks off into or onto an object (shoes, plates, etc) and then the female consumes it, its fucking gross
9) Spitting in the girls mouth (who the fuck does that? try kissing her you useless asshole)