You mentioned that you rarely saw offending posts, but, as I mentioned, there were a lot of posts that were moderated out of public view. Meaning, there were a good number of posts that you (the generic "you") never saw, because they violated the ToS and had to be removed. We don't like to remove posts, because it means we also have to search for quotes of that post, and then discussions about the post, etc., and there is usually a flow to a thread that removals really disrupt.
I may be speaking out of turn here, but I think if there was a, "What was the best reaction to your cock?" thread, that possibly people might play nicely. As I mentioned, whenever you put "When", "First", "At what age", etc., in a title, it never fails that someone always goes below 18.
"What was the best reaction the FIRST time someone saw your cock?", should imply, by the rules of the site, "...in an experience where you were over 18...". For example, "Last week (unless you just turned 18 within the past 6 days :wink: ), this girl/guy saw my cock for the first time, and said..." However, people instead post, "When I was <insert statement violating the rules here> was the first time a girl/guy saw my cock, and said..." For some reason, it's difficult to make people understand that, and yes a few, or in some cases a LOT of, people ruin it for the rest of us.
I hope this clarifies things, but my mind is a bit muddy right now, so I apologize if it just caused more confusion.