all this thread is missing is some sort of survey from some magazine or pie chart, lol
if you go on normal amatuer sites, not big dick ones, youll notice most guys arnt packing anything above 5x4,, honestly.. go on a place like zoig.com, just about every guy, in all the videos and pics, is sportin about 5 inches, a skinny 5 inches, and if were talkin about measuring along the top, id say more liek 4.5" to be honest