Not that I'm a woman but I am gay so I should be somewhat qualified to answer this.
1. Julian Rios - the King unquestioned.
2. Mark Ashley - fucks expertly
3. Mr Marcus - sexy as hell and love his facial expressions when he fucks
4. Dillon Day - great muscular build, masculine, nice deep voice and cute smile
5. Alberto Rey - see above
5. Charles Dera - gorgeous, masculine and love his growls when he fucks
6. Lexington Steele - tall, black, sexy, huge dick and love his screams when he fucks
7. Voodoo - just all round sexy
8. Nacho Vidal - fucks intensely, huge cock and sexy accent
9. Jerry - Gorgeous eyes, great body, sexy accent and love it when he tag teams girls with his dad
10. Mario Rossi - gorgeous, sexy body and sexy accent
11. Ramon Nomar - great muscular build and sexy accent
12. Dick Delaware - 6'3, hunky UFC fighter, need I say more?
13. Michael Stefano - just all round sexy
I hope that helps.