Who has the most overrated dick in gay or straight porn?

[B_Sackballs]

I mean guys you heard were huge but when you saw them you weren't that impressed. Or guys who are big but try make themselves out to be alot bigger? You could show pictures of gay guys but please no penetration. Even though I am not offended by another males body. I don't want to see any penetration.

Anyway. Dick Rambone does it for me. I saw one scene of his and I wasn't impressed at all. Rico Strong has some length but no girth at all. Similar to Wesley Pipes. Some girl was telling me how big Marc Davis was and he only looks to be about 6 inches top.

 

[facumillo]

lex steele (5.5 inch girth maximum)

 

[superboymuscle]

ROCCO and NACHO VIDAL! they are 7,5" and they say are 10" ;D

 

[Snakebyte]

Criss Strokes for sure

 

[prnl0vr]

Christian claimed 9" on another board

 

[FIODOR]

I do not know if their penises are overrated in size, but apart from that 7 / 7.5 is already a more than considerable measure, Nacho and Rocco are lucky (or actresses who have worked with them) to own two of the most purty perfect tools in the industry,
besides being fucking machines, like few others.They are two Greek porn gods.

I always thought, however, despite having a good penis, that Peter North was overrated and still is.

 

[longozzy]

Mr Marcus....

 

[VoyeurEx]

Mr Marcus....

BLASPHEMY! SACRILEGE!

 

[canadianwhiskey]

johnny sins and james dean

 

[tgirlsrgreat]

ramon

 

[CHARLY82]

OVERRATED Lee Stone, Shorty Mac, Ramone
UNDERRATED Mario Cassini, Joel Lawrence, Richard Mann

 

[canadianwhiskey]

OVERRATED Lee Stone, Shorty Mac, Ramone
UNDERRATED Mario Cassini, Joel Lawrence, Richard Mann

shorty mac has arguably the fattest cock in porn history (and since girth is what really matters) I would say that's hardly overrated

 

[Arianne06]

James Deen, not just his dick but everything about him. I just don't get it....

 

[Jeroem83]

James Deen is a great fucker with a sexy dick!

 

[Htt35]

James Deen is a great fucker with a sexy dick!

Yeah James deen is too hot!

 

[3790721]

Interesting thread ! I don't juge a guy by his cock alone so I'll just answer based on my general appreciation lol. The most overrated male pornstar to me, from the top of my head, is definitely Johnny Sins. I see plenty of guys crazy about him here and I sure don't get why lol. He does absolutely nothing for me.

 

[katemarton]

OVERRATED Shane Diesel, Shorty Mac, Isiah Maxwell, Caballo Loco
UNDERRATED Jon jon, Richard Mann, Peter Fitzwell, Ian Tate

 

[JTP3]

OVERRATED Shane Diesel, Shorty Mac, Isiah Maxwell, Caballo Loco
UNDERRATED Jon jon, Richard Mann, Peter Fitzwell, Ian Tate

I do agree with you that Richard Mann is definitely underrated, but Isiah Maxwell?!

I'm not a super Isiah Maxwell fan/stan, but calling Isiah Maxwell just don't sit right with me for some reason.