Who have you compared with?

HungJP94

Cherished Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2015
Posts
29
Media
4
Likes
462
Points
63
Sexuality
50% Straight, 50% Gay
Gender
Male
Went to a party with an old girlfriend at the time playing beer pong til 5am and everyone was pretty lit, can't remember how we got on the topic but my girl kept saying how big I was and a few of the drunk gals said ok let's see and started a compare dicks contest. They got out a tape measure and all. I had two inches on 2nd place but one one beat me in girth. Happy I won length lol but the next day was spent drinking Gatorade and Tylenol
 

bigbucky

Legendary Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2013
Posts
1,284
Media
0
Likes
1,621
Points
208
Location
midwest
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
no one directly, except my older brother. and that was when he found out I had inherited the family's large gene and he had not. my wife has measured me and compared my measurements to her other gfs husbands, boyfriends measurements.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: BigBen and B_er

1IamSmall123

Loved Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Posts
345
Media
12
Likes
736
Points
138
Age
34
Location
USA
Sexuality
100% Straight, 0% Gay
Gender
Male
Just last year, at a private skinny dipping pool party, on a large estate.
I compared with 4 guys, a girl and no shit...a freakin horse!
The guys were commenting about the horse when the girl (wife of one guy) laughed and challenged us to see who was 2nd to the horse.
Well, at least I was bigger than...
her clit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: diver6 and B_er

curtdude

Superior Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Posts
2,390
Media
63
Likes
9,005
Points
518
Location
huntington Beach California
Verification
View
Sexuality
50% Straight, 50% Gay
Gender
Male
I remember an old girl friend's brother shocked me ond day when he told me his sister said i was pretty good in bed. He said that because i was circumcised i was probibly a smaller dude cause circumcised guys are small. I honestly think he just wanted to see my dick we argued a bit my stance was being circumcised has nothing to do with size. I finally stood up and undid my shorts and pulled out my circumcised penis and my balls i think he was impressed he pulled his out too he walked toward me and put his cock next to mine. Soft we were the same i told him that hard is what counts he started to jack his cock and so did i hard as a rock my cock was thicker but we mesured thd same in length. I told him ghat i beat him in the ball catagory mmine were bigger and had more hang. He said thst his sister did like my balls he reached for them and started rubing them real good got me hot i started to jackoff in front of himi was getting ready tto cum he got down and took my cock in his mouthand tottotally swallowed my load shocked but it felt great. Not only did i unload my stuff into Janie i gave it to her brother too.?
 

mandoggy

Experimental Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2012
Posts
23
Media
0
Likes
16
Points
148
Location
Salvador (Bahia, Brazil)
I remember an old girl friend's brother shocked me ond day when he told me his sister said i was pretty good in bed. He said that because i was circumcised i was probibly a smaller dude cause circumcised guys are small. I honestly think he just wanted to see my dick we argued a bit my stance was being circumcised has nothing to do with size. I finally stood up and undid my shorts and pulled out my circumcised penis and my balls i think he was impressed he pulled his out too he walked toward me and put his cock next to mine. Soft we were the same i told him that hard is what counts he started to jack his cock and so did i hard as a rock my cock was thicker but we mesured thd same in length. I told him ghat i beat him in the ball catagory mmine were bigger and had more hang. He said thst his sister did like my balls he reached for them and started rubing them real good got me hot i started to jackoff in front of himi was getting ready tto cum he got down and took my cock in his mouthand tottotally swallowed my load shocked but it felt great. Not only did i unload my stuff into Janie i gave it to her brother too.?
THAT WAS HOT
and probably untrue
 
D

deleted1032794

Guest
I haven't compared with many guys in person, but I have via Facebook chat or text message. About half have actually traded boner pics with me, most of them gay though two of them entirely straight (one shortly after got married and now has a kid) and one who's currently desperately trying to pretend he's straight.

I tend to be bigger or about the same size (of the ones with pics, I have one good friend who's about the same length but not quite as thick, and one who's almost two inches shorter but almost exactly the same girth and weirdly similar shape; I have two other friends who claim to be around the same length and one who's half an inch longer, but I've yet to see photographic proof). There's also one guy who has a pic of his thoroughly average cock on an old porn-reblog-Tumblr (and it's clearly his, since the random crap in the background EXACTLY matches the Facebook profile pic he had at the time), and, when I asked if it was his, he claimed to have a much bigger one, then sent me what was obviously a set of photos screencapped from Grindr.

My favorite story, though, doesn't even include whipping it out... when I was 16, I was working one of my very first jobs, and one other employee--a college guy--and I were closing up one night. There was no one in the store, so we had the TV on, and there was a "Friends" rerun, which started with Monica saying "They say it's the distance between a guy's thumb and his pointer finger" and Ross asking, self-consciously, if he can use either thumb. Matt, who was a cocky guy but had mostly small features (fingers included), stretched out his fingers and braggishly said, "Yeah, that looks about right." So 16-year-old me holds up my hand next to him, and, since I've been described as having E.T. fingers, my finger-span was already bigger. Then I pulled back my double-jointed thumb. I don't think Matt talked to me again the rest of the night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bigred12 and lttle1

chrisjason

Worshipped Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Posts
1,122
Media
0
Likes
20,452
Points
518
Location
Houston, TX
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
This wasn't a direct comparison, at least at the start.

In college fraternity days, the sorority we associated with had a hot dog party on the 4th of July and invited the frat. Our instructions were to wear only basketball shorts and shoes, shirts and underwear were to be left at the house.

When we arrived, there were signs that said: Choose the hot dog that is closest (but not over) the size of your cock. They had five tables for the hot dogs with signs: Regular - 6". Jumbo - 7", Bun Length - 8", Footlong - 12." They watched for which table we queued up at, teased us, and laughed about it. They wrote R, J, B, or F on our chests as we doctored up our hot dogs.

After eating, they brought all of the F's (there weren't too many) to the front and said, "Prove it!" If you didn't plop out a long one, they gave you a chance to boner it up. Guys who'd chosen footlongs and couldn't measure up caught some ridicule (as well as being nearly naked and boned up).

Then, the brought the R's up and had a tiniest cock contest. Everyone laughed as the large field was winnowed down to Mr. Tiny who had to wear a hot dog crown the rest of the night.

It was lots of fun and none of the guys cared if they had to flash the girls -- even Mr. Tiny, who claimed to have made it with a dozen sorority girls in the weeks afterwards.
 

chrisjason

Worshipped Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Posts
1,122
Media
0
Likes
20,452
Points
518
Location
Houston, TX
Sexuality
No Response
Gender
Male
I marched in a 6-man color guard for a parade which ended at a public park. By then, the six of us had to piss badly. All of the port-a-johns were busy, so we circled up in the grass and pulled them out. One guy said, "Can't put it away until everyone finishes." Soon, all six streams stopped and I started to put my away. Another guy said, "Not yet. I"m not done comparing." We waited for the comparison to finish (and everyone was comparing, not just the guy who admitted it).
 

thebubblegum112233

Legendary Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2020
Posts
692
Media
0
Likes
1,038
Points
113
Location
New York (United States)
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
My gallery has a picture comparing cocks with Greg (mine's the thick one), but since no one here knows Greg, here are some better-known individuals I have had the privilege of a, um, firsthand comparison with:

Thinner than me, but longer:
Michael Brandon, Element Eclipse, Adam Foxx, Red (as seen on Machofucker)

Around my girth, but longer:
Cutler X

Roughly similar overall size:
Mack (as in macksf.com, not firsthand, comparative measurement made using Titpig's ass), Erik Hunter

Around my length, but thinner:
Jeff Palmer, Scott Spears, Matt Sizemore

Smaller overall:
Lots, but a gentleman doesn't say.

Comparisons I'd like a chance to make firsthand:
Rocco Steele, Antonio Biaggi, Esteban


I would absolutely die if you could describe the MackSF comparison. Your profile is amazing, and I love your cock. Mack is the man I first realized I 1 - love daddys, hairy men, huge dicks and muscle and 2 - wanted to take my virgin hole. I wish I had any more of his stuff outside of his (sadly) not-updated website
 
  • Like
Reactions: deleted1299116

Fishsqueezee69

Superior Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Mar 23, 2020
Posts
1,079
Media
34
Likes
4,337
Points
308
Location
Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
99% Gay, 1% Straight
Gender
Male
Only a few times in person. I've got a pretty small penis (3.5") and used to be really embarrassed and self-conscious about it ( I've just started to accept it).

One time was with my best friend in highschool who was also asian (and straight). We were hanging out overnight as his place and out of nowhere he said something like "let's get naked!" I really liked him so I was really into the idea. We stripped down and compared. Soft and hard he was bigger than me. We played with eachother's dicks and I kind of teased a blowjob, but he got wigged out and didn't go through with it.

Another time was with my little brother. Same kind of deal, we were just hanging out alone and he asked if I wanted to compare. I was kind of hesitant, but I trusted him and knew it wouldn't get too weird. We each went into our rooms and came out naked. I remember him laughing at me and how small I was which got me hard which then got him hard. We had to have been at least 7" uncut. Really embarrassing but really hot too.

The most recent time was at a party with a bunch of friends at an apartment. We had been drinking a lot and all the gay kids there decided to compare. There were 4 of us and we all got into the bathroom, dropped our pants and started comparing. One guy was black and ended up being my bf, huge, thick 8" cock. The other guys had average size dicks, maybe 6"? We started jacking off until someobody started knocking on the door and kind of killed the mood.

Small or not, you shouldn't be too ashamed of your cock. I would love to see it ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: diver6

Fishsqueezee69

Superior Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Mar 23, 2020
Posts
1,079
Media
34
Likes
4,337
Points
308
Location
Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
99% Gay, 1% Straight
Gender
Male
I know there are a bunch of threads like this, but I am starting a new one...

Have you ever compared you penis with anyone else? friends, brothers, cousins? how big are you they?


at camp my friends always compared but i always thought i was small so i didn't compare, would just watch...my cousin and i have talked about it, he is a little over 6.5" im a over 7" not quite 7.5, but i am 6'4 and he is 5'7, and my older brother(he is 5'10) claims to be 10", I've never seen it since we were younger, but many people who have seen have told me he is huge...I have 2 other brothers but I don't know how big they are at all...

Well I am gay so I have compared to many guys but as far as o other than that just my cousin. He had bigger nuts and my penis was bigger lol
 

ericbear

Superior Member
Verified
Gold
Joined
Oct 14, 2002
Posts
2,931
Media
35
Likes
6,372
Points
568
Location
Santa Ana (California, United States)
Verification
View
Sexuality
100% Gay, 0% Straight
Gender
Male
I would absolutely die if you could describe the MackSF comparison. Your profile is amazing, and I love your cock. Mack is the man I first realized I 1 - love daddys, hairy men, huge dicks and muscle and 2 - wanted to take my virgin hole. I wish I had any more of his stuff outside of his (sadly) not-updated website
I never compared dick-to-dick with Mack. I was in Palm Springs, and played with someone that Mack had fucked in several porn videos (porn name Titpig, I think). He commented on the similarity of our cocks. Mack was obviously impressed with mine...One day I'm in San Francisco walking up to Starbucks. Mack is sitting on a chair outside. As I pass, he smacks me on the crotch, and says "How do you always show a bulge like that? Mine shrivels up to nothing! " Once he asked if I could help him out with a scene for a client, but as I was just a frequent visitor from far away, it wasn't going to work out.

Since I made the comparison list, I have found I sometimes misjudged. For example, at a party just before covid shut everything down, Cutler X shows up, and we both took turns fucking the gogo dancer, who afterward remarked "OK, Cutler's a little longer, but you're thicker!"
 

thebubblegum112233

Legendary Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2020
Posts
692
Media
0
Likes
1,038
Points
113
Location
New York (United States)
Sexuality
90% Straight, 10% Gay
Gender
Male
I never compared dick-to-dick with Mack. I was in Palm Springs, and played with someone that Mack had fucked in several porn videos (porn name Titpig, I think). He commented on the similarity of our cocks. Mack was obviously impressed with mine...One day I'm in San Francisco walking up to Starbucks. Mack is sitting on a chair outside. As I pass, he smacks me on the crotch, and says "How do you always show a bulge like that? Mine shrivels up to nothing! " Once he asked if I could help him out with a scene for a client, but as I was just a frequent visitor from far away, it wasn't going to work out.

Since I made the comparison list, I have found I sometimes misjudged. For example, at a party just before covid shut everything down, Cutler X shows up, and we both took turns fucking the gogo dancer, who afterward remarked "OK, Cutler's a little longer, but you're thicker!"

God, that sounds amazing. I would to love experience you and your cock, those stories *umf*, wish I was there. You must bulge big then for Mack to see. How big are you when boned up? Are you also built like Mack?