If there were public transportation here, I wouldn't mind supporting it or using. I live out in the boonies, in the mountains, and there is no public transportation here. Some of the nearby small cities have a limited bus system, but it comes nowhere near me. There's not even a Greyhound station within 40 miles of here.
Making the necessary allowances for rural populations and their specific needs and then extrapolating them onto a largely suburban/urban population is crummy policy.
In rural areas, where the roads are lousy and distances interminable, SUVs can make sense if the are 4WD and are large enough to haul all your shit around. That's not what we're really discussing.
Private transportation is an expensive, dangerous luxury in most of the places where most Americans actually live, and SUVs exacerbate the problem with their poor fuel efficiency and crummy emissions standards.
If options in rapid transit (including Light Rail Vehicles) were even on the table, I wonder how many drivers today might not find greater freedom by taking it than being chained to their cars/trucks/SUVs.
How many vehicular fatalities and DUIs would be avoided if there were other options? How might local air quality improve? How might we learn to socialize better and interact in a more civilized fashion?
I spent most of my adult life living in Boston, New York and Paris where urban densities and the realities of city living precluded owning a car. I was entirely divorced from the car culture except for the occasional rentals and overall very happy. The expense of owning, insuring and maintaining a car was shifted to the higher rent and other cost-of-living expenses associated with living in those places.
In 1999 I moved to Connecticut for a great job and ran into my first culture clash. A well-heeled, affluent suburban client asked me what I missed most about the city. Without hesitation I answered: "The subway."
She looked at me as if I'd thrown up on her lunch. "What", she asked, "was so great about the subway?"
I thought for a second and replied: "I used to read two newspapers per day, and dozens of magazines each month. I never worried about finding a parking spot or feeding a meter. My subway pass cost me $40 per month. I just spent $10,000 on a five-year-old car that will probably need to be replaced before I've finished paying it off, plus insurance, plus all the gas I need to keep it running. And I consider the 45 minutes it took me this morning to get here totally wasted."
If 1/3 of the money we spend on highways and on gas were poured into reliable, clean, efficient rapid transit imagine the various improvements we'd make to our lives. Imagine how different the streets would look if buildings and not parking lots lined local streets.
I am currently living in Ft Lauderdale, where a car is considered absolutely a requirement. Density is relatively low (but this is changing as small single-family homes are torn down and two or three townhomes built on the same lots), streets are wider and distances much greater than in New England. The bus service is completely unreliable, surprisingly expensive, goes nowhere and stops too soon. A seven-minute drive is a 40-minute walk or 75 minutes by bus (sometimes much longer). There are no shelters for people waiting in the blistering summer heat or caught in frequent tropical downpours.
In order to remain eligible for government assistance for my HIV meds after I lost my insurance, I cannot earn more than $2000 per month. My rent is $750, utilities can run more than $300 per month. My Mini Cooper, purchased when I first arrived and still had insurance ran, with payment, insurance and gas upwards of $650, which made eating difficult and I made the decision to let it go before it was repossessed.
This is not some philosophical discussion for me. This is the reality of my existence.