IrishGirl, would she really hate her husband or herself for accepting this proposal? She doesn't have to agree to this; she does have a mind of her own, doesn't she?
Although I could never agree to such a thing, I don't condemn it. If both parties have discussed the matter, and if (and only if) both parties are willing.... There are the consequences.
I honestly think she would.
Not to sound sexist, but men have a very different view of paying for a sexual partner than women do. I know many men who have paid for an escort or a prostitute, a massage aka topless handjob, a blowjob, or whatever and it doesn't bother them one bit; but I cannot think of a single woman who would not feel ashamed, debased, worthless, humiliated or some similar emotion when she comes to the full realization that her husband had to pay someone to fuck her. I think that once her little fantasy is fulfilled and she wakes up, she will be crushed.
It's like he is saying to her that she isn't attractive or seductive enough for a man to want her. One of the most satisfying things about being a woman is knowing that you can attract men. It's a very powerful and exciting feeling. Most women I know (and probably most women in general) could leave the house, find a man and have him agree to have sex with them in 20 minutes or less. Very few men can accomplish that, lol. I think this aspect of the situation is pretty much lost on the men reading this thread. Think of the thing that makes you feel most like a man (being a father, providing for your family, your occupation, etc). Now take that away. Wouldn't not feeling like a man be devastating? I think she is going to wake up and realize that she traded part of herself for $200.
Years ago my partner and I went through a phase where we enjoyed watching each other with a third party. Part of the thrill is seeing how much someone else wants what you already have. Paying for it takes that away. It's a job for them rather than an erotic encounter. I don't think any woman wants to realize that making love to her is work that requires financial compensation.
We knew many people and had many friends who experimented as well, and none of their relationships survived. It takes a certain kind of mindset to have someones heart and mind all to yourself, but to be sharing them sexually. The majority of people who think they can handle it actually can't. We saw many people who thought it was hot and exciting, then sooner or later, things got ugly.
Also, the fact that she just wants a big dick set off alarm bells for me. It's like she doesn't give a damn about her husbands feelings. When you love someone, you love them no matter what size their dick is. There are ways to remain faithful and be fulfilled sexually.
I just think there are too many wrongs in this situation and not enough rights. Neither one of them really knows what they are getting into. Bottom line ... It's their marriage and if they want to risk it, that's their choice.