My reaction was very similar to Holly's. I'd always said that I wouldn't have a relationship with someone who didn't have a reasonable sized dick, that for me to have a relationship with someone he had to have all the factors I considered of any importance, but what we say and what we do when we find ourselves in that situation can be different. I met this guy, really nice looking, great personality, we had a few dates then when it got to sex I discovered he was small, smaller than 4 inches, I didn't run screaming from my bedroom, I didn't indicate that I found his dick tiny and I carried on, like Holly we messed around but we didn't have penetrative sex, I didn't want to hurt his feelings either but neither would I carry on seeing him when he didn't measure up to what I wanted out of a man. To some women size isn't important and it would be considered a trivial reason to stop seeing a guy, but to me it's important that a man has everything I want, so a small penis is just as much of a bar to seeing him as a terrible personality would be.