Butt plugs

The problem I have with butt plugs is that the base gets painful digging into my cheeks after a while. I find Dildos more comfortable to keep in place for an extended period of time. Problem is, they work their way out if standing or walking. I bought a pair of underwear that are supposed to keep a toy in place, but while they're comfortable to wear, the cloth isn't firm enough to really keep the toy in place. Anyone have any suggestions for a comfortable product (underwear or harness) that will keep the dildo from slipping out?
Have you tried wearing a thong to hold your toy in place? The string should hold it better since it would be right up against the dildo.
 
I did at first, but that didn't work out well, as there wasn't enough structure (elastic at waist, or too much give to the thong) to do much. That's why i bought the underwear that was supposed to be made for the purpose. But same problem with too much give to the fabric. Harnesses I've looked at look like they'd just dig into the flesh, so I've been hesitant to buy one. So thought I'd post and see if others have found anything they could recommend that they found comfortable.
 
Perhaps I need to learn to sew so I could make something out of heavier fabric with more structure like a soft denim. I could use a comfortable pair of underwear as a pattern.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mushroomcap
So I am a tight bottom, my hole is tight, I have just purchased a beginners butt plug trio. But I’ve read on Reddit that butt plugs don’t actually help your ability to take dick and they don’t actually loosen up your sphincter because the big bit of the butt plug actually goes inside your bum and it’s only a thin but that actually is holding your bum hole open? What all of you guys think to this!
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldscorpguy
Plug works very well for me
Work up in sizes, stretch it
Thank you so much for replying! So they definitely help you in terms of being able to take dick? As in you think they stretch your hole? Amy tips/advice other than work up in sizes? Or can you give me a short explanation? I really would appreciate it! Thank you for your reply!
 
So I am a tight bottom, my hole is tight, I have just purchased a beginners butt plug trio. But I’ve read on Reddit that butt plugs don’t actually help your ability to take dick and they don’t actually loosen up your sphincter because the big bit of the butt plug actually goes inside your bum and it’s only a thin but that actually is holding your bum hole open? What all of you guys think to this!
Hi, I'm tight too, and have used a plug prior to bottoming for years. I do get the bit about the thinner neck of it and the wider part inside, but it's the first few inches inside that you are trying to open, more than your actual hole.

I find also that using a plug helps me to relax the muscles and not tense against the intrusion of a cock. I often leave the plug in so the top can remove it or fuck me with it a few times . The plug definitely helps with that initial penetrative pain.
 
Experimented a little with plugs and I'm not sure. I love anal play so maybe I need to persevere with them.
Just went to see some new clients about some renovation work. I was very horny prior so wore my cock ring, a medium butt plug and a thong.
It felt pretty good to be fair.
 
Experimented a little with plugs and I'm not sure. I love anal play so maybe I need to persevere with them.
Just went to see some new clients about some renovation work. I was very horny prior so wore my cock ring, a medium butt plug and a thong.
It felt pretty good to be fair.
Haha that made me laugh! Kudos to you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Calida
Hi, I'm tight too, and have used a plug prior to bottoming for years. I do get the bit about the thinner neck of it and the wider part inside, but it's the first few inches inside that you are trying to open, more than your actual hole.

I find also that using a plug helps me to relax the muscles and not tense against the intrusion of a cock. I often leave the plug in so the top can remove it or fuck me with it a few times . The plug definitely helps with that initial penetrative pain.
It can be annoying being tight can’t it! Tbh I know I shouldn’t but I’ve recently gotten into a habit of smoking before however I’m now wanting to stop smoking so that’s why I’m trying to loosen myself in other ways! I don’t like the idea of poppers as I have history of mental health and I don’t want to damage my brain! I have recently seen that you can get butt plugs which are really thick at the base which concentrate on the actual opening of your butt hole! Idk I’ll experiment I guess and see what works best! Thanks for your reply
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldscorpguy
So I am a tight bottom, my hole is tight, I have just purchased a beginners butt plug trio. But I’ve read on Reddit that butt plugs don’t actually help your ability to take dick and they don’t actually loosen up your sphincter because the big bit of the butt plug actually goes inside your bum and it’s only a thin but that actually is holding your bum hole open? What all of you guys think to this!
You hang on to your tight hole, it'll soon get used and less tight. If you're trying to open your hole, a dildo is more useful to you, butt plugs, as you've noted, have a thinner neck - which means your asshole clams up and holds the plug in place - what an experience.
Using a dilator opens up not only your sphinctre but everything - but it falls out if you want to "wear" it for extended use, like shopping
 
You hang on to your tight hole, it'll soon get used and less tight. If you're trying to open your hole, a dildo is more useful to you, butt plugs, as you've noted, have a thinner neck - which means your asshole clams up and holds the plug in place - what an experience.
Using a dilator opens up not only your sphinctre but everything - but it falls out if you want to "wear" it for extended use, like shopping
Do you think I should go for a dilator instead? I’m basically just wanting anal sex to be less painful! I only really have anal sex once every two weeks but when I do I always end up having to have a smoke so I can relax to take it!
 
I'm going to be devil's advocate here and say small plugs are good to keep using, even after you've graduated to a larger size. I have 4 plugs getting progressively bigger, and I still use them all. One or more of them make their way into my ass every day.

I look at it as a workout for a specific muscle, my anal sphincter. The smallest one is 4.5 inch circumference, the largest one is 7.5 inch circumference. The ones I use the most are 5.5 circumference and 6.5 circumference. When I'm using them, my hole is constantly gripping down on them and relaxing around them. The benefit is that my fuck hole is easy to get into, but a tight grip once your cock gets inside. At least, that's what the guys tell me. :cool::imp:
 
The problem I have with butt plugs is that the base gets painful digging into my cheeks after a while. I find Dildos more comfortable to keep in place for an extended period of time. Problem is, they work their way out if standing or walking. I bought a pair of underwear that are supposed to keep a toy in place, but while they're comfortable to wear, the cloth isn't firm enough to really keep the toy in place. Anyone have any suggestions for a comfortable product (underwear or harness) that will keep the dildo from slipping out?
A butt plug with a T shaped base is much more comfortable for long term wear, for standing or walking you need a butt plug rather than a dildo as a butt plug is held in place by your anal muscles on the neck. The exception is a weighted internal toy where your anal muscles work to retain the toy against gravity, so it moves up and down inside- quite a different feeling from a butt plug or dildo. I'm not aware of any commercially made items.
 
So I am a tight bottom, my hole is tight, I have just purchased a beginners butt plug trio. But I’ve read on Reddit that butt plugs don’t actually help your ability to take dick and they don’t actually loosen up your sphincter because the big bit of the butt plug actually goes inside your bum and it’s only a thin but that actually is holding your bum hole open? What all of you guys think to this!
Maybe, but for a beginner a lot of it is actually getting used to having something inside without struggling against the action of the rectum- the body trues to empty the rectum when it feels full, hence the initial "need to poop" sensation when you start with bum toys. Use the toilet and clean up, lube up and slowly slip the smallest toy inside. Leave it in as you sit and just get used to the sensation of being full without your body trying to empty- it takes a while but in a week or so you'll be much more relaxed with something inside- then you can start to get used to something little bigger.