Can An Ass Be "too Loose?"

I have fisted a few guys and the next time I fist them, it still feels tight. The sphincter is a muscle that stretches and contracts. You would be surprised how much it can stretch.

I wonder why some guys assholes looks like the inside of a cinnamon donut. Like that look like they’ve been used one too many times. Don’t get me started on prolapse
 
I wonder why some guys assholes looks like the inside of a cinnamon donut. Like that look like they’ve been used one too many times. Don’t get me started on prolapse

That's a bit of an exaggeration in that people's asses, even folks into fisting and intentional prolapsing, don't stay like that 24/7. If you relax enough your ass will be able to accommodate large things, and with stretching over time, it can accommodate REALLY large things. But your sphincter will still be able to close such that unless you've done actual tearing-type damage, you'll be able to maintain continence.

But @Big_Daddy999, if you're just getting fucked by anything smaller than a fence post, you'll be fine.
 
To give an angle to the question, now we know that asses have unbelievable flexibility: can a serial elbow-deep fistee still enjoy "normal cock in normal sex" ? Or do we need to have the Jumbo IV and Tarzan XL stand by?
 
I can’t speak to fisting, but for regular ol’ fucking, I’ve had many many cocks in my hole, of varying length and girth. And it appears the guys still consider me a pretty tight fuck. That’s just going by the comments and responses I get from my top guys.

I’ve never been fisted, though, so I’ll let more experienced anal players speak to that.
 
have not had an arm to the bicep but do know the feeling of a good punch fisting. It was just two days later that a very nice man used my ass as his toy and his comments were that i was as tight as a nun! So, yes, the muscles do return to the regular, although probably not, original tightness.
 
have not had an arm to the bicep but do know the feeling of a good punch fisting. It was just two days later that a very nice man used my ass as his toy and his comments were that i was as tight as a nun! So, yes, the muscles do return to the regular, although probably not, original tightness.

Tight as a nun. Love that expression!
 
yeah obviously best advise is try not to get tear damage always ask for lube or plenty of spit to get that ass well accommodating. If you keep damaging your arse then obviously the muscles may not be as strong, also breathe and take your time.
 
Once you lose your anal virginity and stuff your ass with things like penises, toys, vegetables etc on a regular basis, you definitely lose the original tightness.

But the original extreme tightness of a virgin ass is not healthy, imo. Since my teenage years I have haemorrhoids that come and go occasionally. And this is caused by the veins there, The muscle is so tight that blood cannot flow freely. But after training my ass regularly with large toys, I have remarkably loosened my sphincter and the haemorrhoids disappeared. My hole feels relaxed all the time. That's a nice feeling. Yet I have no fecal incontinence issues.

A looser ass is healthier.

Besides, there is a treatment method for haemorrhoids and anal fissures that is called anal dilatation where the doctor performs fisting on the patient who is under anaesthesia. :D His goal is to loosen the muscles and let the blood flow freely.

In short, we all get looser. We are no nuns anymore. But anus takes care of itself and turns to its initial position after heavy use.
 
Once you lose your anal virginity and stuff your ass with things like penises, toys, vegetables etc on a regular basis, you definitely lose the original tightness.

But the original extreme tightness of a virgin ass is not healthy, imo. Since my teenage years I have haemorrhoids that come and go occasionally. And this is caused by the veins there, The muscle is so tight that blood cannot flow freely. But after training my ass regularly with large toys, I have remarkably loosened my sphincter and the haemorrhoids disappeared. My hole feels relaxed all the time. That's a nice feeling. Yet I have no fecal incontinence issues.

A looser ass is healthier.

Besides, there is a treatment method for haemorrhoids and anal fissures that is called anal dilatation where the doctor performs fisting on the patient who is under anaesthesia. :D His goal is to loosen the muscles and let the blood flow freely.

In short, we all get looser. We are no nuns anymore. But anus takes care of itself and turns to its initial position after heavy use.

Medical doctor here, and I have never come accross "fisting under anaesthesia" as a treatment-modality for haemorrhoids.
 
I can’t speak to fisting, but for regular ol’ fucking, I’ve had many many cocks in my hole, of varying length and girth. And it appears the guys still consider me a pretty tight fuck. That’s just going by the comments and responses I get from my top guys.

I’ve never been fisted, though, so I’ll let more experienced anal players speak to that.
As a proud fist (and large toy) pig I will say that average size guys still feel fine in my ass if they are fucking me before doing anything else. But, when you get into group play and the like, the longer I am getting used the less an average cock is going to feel. So, when I was at a huge sex party at a club in SF during Folsom, the first guys to go in me that night felt a solid ass that could milk their cocks. By the end of the night (nearly three dozen partners later) I had been fucked and fisted so much that the last guy to have me gave up trying to feel anything when he fucked me and just stuck his hand in alongside and jerked his cock off inside me. It was super hot. Back to my hotel room and a few hours sleep and I awoke ready for more and took an average size guy and hung guy to start the day and both of them could feel me just fine.
 
Medical doctor here, and I have never come accross "fisting under anaesthesia" as a treatment-modality for haemorrhoids.
Well there is such a treatment. You may not have seen it or you may not apply it. Or this treatment method may have been completely vanished. But there is, or there was. Why would I make it up?