Defining Music for a generation

[gjorg]

I listened to people like the Gratefull dead since I was 9 till about 29. Names like Garcia and Slick defined my generation for a generation. What music today still can define a generations music or politics for a decade or two? I played Verdi for dinner tonight but thats not the question. Who dominates in that field for todays generation? I came up with this while listening to ---------- on SNL tonight. Boy they Sucked!

 

[rob_just_rob]

The world moves faster than it did in the heyday of the Grateful Dead.

 

[THEEman]

anything indie and uncool. dark brooding but yet fansical at the same time

 

[Quite Irate]

There is no defining music, sadly. Product is king in today's musical world. There are always interesting artists cropping up, but none of them are popular on the scale of rappers and hip hop crap. Electronic music might actually follow rap and hip hop.

 

[D_Hyacinth Harrytwat]

There is no defining music, sadly. Product is king in today's musical world. There are always interesting artists cropping up, but none of them are popular on the scale of rappers and hip hop crap. Electronic music might actually follow rap and hip hop.

That whole "product is king" thing makes me want to cry. It's easier than before to make it as a band. There shouldn't be music to hate - either like it or don't - but I really think that hate is appropriate to describe the way I feel for certain "musicians" *gag*.

Maybe I'm being a snob but I don't appreciate a lot of current music as being music.

 

[whatireallywant]

There has generally been at least two major musical movements or styles that define a decade. There was in the 1940s, 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, and yes, even the 1990s. However, this has failed to happen in the 2000s decade.

I believe the reason is the increasing corporate dominance of radio, and media generally. There are fewer and fewer independent outlets that play "risky" (as in not guaranteed to be "commercial" enough to sell...) music. This saddens me. There is actually good music being performed now, and good new bands. You just won't hear most of them on the radio. A few good bands do break through, but not very many.

 

[THEEman]

That whole "product is king" thing makes me want to cry. It's easier than before to make it as a band. There shouldn't be music to hate - either like it or don't - but I really think that hate is appropriate to describe the way I feel for certain "musicians" *gag*.

Maybe I'm being a snob but I don't appreciate a lot of current music as being music.

you mean rap or something else?

 

[D_Hyacinth Harrytwat]

you mean rap or something else?

I just mean music created for money's sake, not music created for music's sake. I don't consider Rap as music but more like spoken art, or maybe a collaboration between the two... And in that case, if it's about the money, add it to my "hate" list.

 

[Quite Irate]

I just mean music created for money's sake, not music created for music's sake. I don't consider Rap as music but more like spoken art, or maybe a collaboration between the two... And in that case, if it's about the money, add it to my "hate" list.

If you want less commercial rap that may have some sort of poetic value, check out slam. Even famous slam poets aren't corporate sponsored.

 

[D_Kay_Sarah_Sarah]

I feel sorry for this generation that in the future the music that defines their generation will be emo.

 

[THEEman]

the appropriate term if you were one of us and "cool" is indie haha

if you call it emo your a wanna be. its so stupid

 

[THEDUDER]

indie and emo are not the same thing

 

[THEDUDER]

hipinion.com/forums


Home: Pitchfork

 

[D_Hyacinth Harrytwat]

If you want less commercial rap that may have some sort of poetic value, check out slam. Even famous slam poets aren't corporate sponsored.

Thanks, I'll check that out! I love rappers who have a real way with words.

 

[D_Sir Fitzwilly Wankheimer III]

Gov't Mule is the best band.

 

[psidom]

slam is an awesome movie,saul williams is outta this world.
other good hiphop acts are out there,aesop rock,defjux,haiku de tat,
blade, and i like alot of apocalyptic folk.
acts like cocorosie,joanna newsom,pentangle,milenasong,the books.
stuff like that,

but music to define this generation i think is indie.
people like cat power,modest mouse,wolf parade,smog.

 

[Principessa]

I listened to people like the Gratefull dead since I was 9 till about 29. Names like Garcia and Slick defined my generation for a generation. What music today still can define a generations music or politics for a decade or two? I played Verdi for dinner tonight but thats not the question. Who dominates in that field for todays generation? I came up with this while listening to ---------- on SNL tonight. Boy they Sucked!

I graduated high school in 1984. I think the music genre that defined my generation would be an eclectic mix of disco, glam rock, and rap.

 

[THEDUDER]

he didn' ask about your generation

 

[Principessa]

he didn' ask about your generation

He should have, my generation is far more interesting and had great music. This emo shit sucks.

 

[psidom]

her generation is actually what our generation had to look up to.
with out grandmaster flash you don't have alot of what we do today.
!RESPECT NJQT.:biggrin1: