Does size really matter?

Gotta have more of this. I actually found myself wondering "what happened next" randomly today at work. I think that's the mark of a good storyteller. Waiting for more!
 
After showering and changing, Nick and Jennifer drove together to Stacey’s house. As Stacey cooked diner, Nick flipped on the TV and started watching Sports Center. The announcers discussed the day’s college football games and showed Nick being taken out and Derek scoring four touchdowns.

As Jennifer squeezed Nick’s hand encouragingly, the doorbell rang and Stacey went to open it. “Well hello there, stud!” Stacey gave Derek a big kiss as he walked in the door. Jennifer then jumped off the couch and gave Derek a hug that lasted a bit too long in Nick’s opinion.

Throughout dinner, Derek was in a good mood and flirted with both the girls while Nick stayed quiet. He felt weird about the night before and humiliated about the game, but whenever Derek stood up to get a refill, Nick couldn’t help to glance at Derek’s crotch, his eyes searching for that massive bulge.

After dinner, the four college students went into the living room of Stacey’s apartment, which was fairly small. There was only a couch and a chair and Derek sat down in the middle of the couch. Stacey and Jennifer sat on both sides of him and Nick took the chair a few feet away.

“Hmmm…what should we do?” Stacey asked.

“How about a movie?” Jennifer said.

“Nah, that’s boring. I want you sexy ladies to have a good evening,” Derek said, smiling. Skinny dipping the previous weekend had clearly given him some new ideas.

“What about cards?” Stacey asked. “Strip poker.”

“Ummm…I’m kinda tired,” Nick said, getting nervous.

“Honey, don’t be boring. We all basically saw each other naked last weekend,” Jennifer said. “This will be fun!”

Nick was out-voted three to one. As Derek started dealing the cards, Nick prepared for a long night.

The rules of the game were simple: each person started with eight pieces of clothing and the game was five-card draw. Each person could exchange two cards from the deck to form as good of a hand as possible and the loser had to remove an article of clothing.

The first couple of rounds went really well for Nick. Stacey and Jennifer each lost two of the first four rounds and removed their shoes. Then Derek lost a hand and took off his shirt, exposing his chiseled torso and a few bruises from the football game.

Then Nick lost three hands in a row and slipped off his shoes and watch. They kept playing for thirty minutes until Nick was in his boxers, Stacey and Jennifer both had their bras and underwear on, and Derek had shorts, boxers, and a watch on. Seeing Stacey and Jennifer in their sexy lingerie sent a jolt through Nick and his 4.5-incher was tenting his boxers.

“Wow Nick, excited are ya?” Stacey laughed at him.

Nick felt embarrassed, but not as much as when he lost the next hand. As he slowly stood up, Derek smiled and said, “Come on dude, show us your monster.”

Stacey hadn’t seen Nick’s cock yet, so she assumed he was about as hung as Derek. When Nick pulled down his boxers and a thin, boy-sized penis popped up, she gasped in surprise. Nick noticed her reaction and quickly sat down, his entire body turning red and his penis shriveling up in the cool breeze.

“Alright, let’s keep playing,” Jennifer said. She had seen Derek smirking all night and was starting to get curious about what he was hiding under his shorts. Was he a shower like Nick said or a grower hung like a porn star?

Derek lost the next round and removed his watch, then Stacey and Jennifer each lost the next ones. As they slowly unclasped their bras, Derek started getting more excited and a tent formed in his shorts. He lost the next round and stripped to black boxer briefs, which revealed a sizeable bulge.

Jennifer couldn’t help but stare at the large snake in Derek’s underwear. She had never seen anything like it. When she lost the next round and slipped her panties off, she was almost in a trance.

Derek’s voice broke her trance. “What are we going to do once we’re all naked?” he asked.

“Hmm…how about we play for dares?” Stacey replied.

“Cool, let’s start playing dares now,” Derek replied. Nick and Jennifer didn’t seem to have much say in the matter. Jennifer was too distracted by the mouthwateringly huge hunk of meat bulging from Derek’s boxers. Based on what Nick had said about Derek being a grower, she didn’t expect it to be so large. Had Derek stuffed something down his shorts or had Nick, who was busy gaping at Stacey’s boobs, lied to his longtime girlfriend?

Derek won the next hand and Jennifer lost. “Hmm…what should we do?” Derek looked at Jennifer, who was staring lustfully at his crotch. “How about you come over here and take off my boxers?”

Nick was stunned. Had this freshman punk really just asked his senior girlfriend to take off his undies for him? Nick was about to put a stop to this, but he was amazed to see that Jennifer was already on the floor in front of Derek with her hand on his chiseled abs. She was literally drooling as her eyes fixated on the obnoxious bulge enclosed by Derek’s black Calvin Klein boxer briefs.

“You ready for this?” Derek asked.

“Oh, I’m ready,” she replied. Like an eager virgin, Jennifer grabbed the waistband of his underwear and pulled them down. The thick flesh of Derek’s cock came into view. It extended downward until it was halfway to his knees and then it snapped up into Jennifer’s face.

“Holy shit,” she said. “This thing is fucking huge!”

Derek kicked off his boxers from his ankles and gave his cock a quick tug. He enjoyed seeing Jennifer on her knees before his cock and wanted to shove it in her mouth right away, but he also knew that he needed to be patient. He backed away a bit and gave Jennifer a full-body view. As she looked at this horse-hung freshman stud, she noticed her boyfriend sitting next to him. Nick’s penis was still shriveled up and the 2-inch softie looked tiny compared to Derek’s battleship.

Nick’s petite manhood perked to attention during the next hand when he lost and Stacey won. “Hey Nick, why don’t you take my panties off?” she said. “With your mouth…”

Nick crawled over to Stacey and gently used his teeth to remove Stacey’s thong. Her moist honey pot smelled delicious and Nick’s penis started throbbing.

Jennifer was a bit upset that Nick was so enthralled with Stacey, but she also smiled, knowing that this gave her the freedom to perform “dares” on Derek.
 
During the next hand, Derek won and Stacey and Jennifer tied for last. “Hey pretty ladies, why don’t you kiss each other for a bit?”

Jennifer stared at Stacey in surprise. Despite being on the cheerleading squad for most of her life, she had never done anything like this. But the idea of being naked with Stacey and kissing her didn’t seem repulsive, so she decided to give it a shot.

Stacey seemed a bit more experienced with same-sex kissing and she came up to Jennifer and gave her a warm, tender kiss. As Jennifer’s mouth opened and the girls french-kissed, Stacey grabbed Jennifer’s breast and tenderly squeezed it. Jennifer moaned in response.

“Umm, I think this is enough,” Nick said. The truth was that he was loving the show, but he was also about to cum. The make-out session of the two hottest girls he knew was too much to handle.

“Alright, let’s play another round,” Derek said. Jennifer won the next hand and Derek and Nick tied for last place. As Jennifer glanced at Nick and Derek’s throbbing cocks, an idea popped into her head. She didn’t want to humiliate her boyfriend, but she also wanted to pay him back for lying to her about Derek’s manhood. “I’ll be right back,” she said.

Jennifer returned with a ruler in her hand and said, “I want to measure both of your cocks.”

Nick groaned but he knew that there was nothing he could do. The damage was already done and the only way he could end the night by cumming inside of Stacey or Jennifer was by playing along.

As Nick stood up, Jennifer walked over to him and put the ruler on top of his erect penis. He was harder than ever and smiled a bit when Jennifer read off “four and three-quarters inches.” Jennifer then crawled over to Derek, who was stroking his shaft with two hands to get it harder.

“Hey Jen, could you give me a hand…or two? I don’t think it’s at full mast yet…” As Derek kept one hand on the bottom of his cock, Jen placed her two small hands on the rest of his shaft and started massaging up and down. Nick and Stacey were amazed. It took three hands to stroke Derek’s cock to full mast!

Jennifer stared at the massive cock a few inches from her face as it grew bigger, longer, and stronger. It was so thick that her hand couldn’t fit completely around the shaft, but she kept stroking vigorously until Derek said, “Okay, that’s good.”

As Jennifer laid the ruler down on top of Derek’s steel rod, she gasped at the result. “Nine and three-quarters inches…holy fucking shit! Nick, come over here.” Jennifer beckoned her boyfriend and grabbed his penis in one hand and Derek’s dick in the other. The comparison was absurd: Derek's was twice as long and twice as thick.

As Jennifer pulled on his dick, Nick looked down at Derek’s cock and quickly turned away, cumming uncontrollably on the floor. “Haha,” Stacey laughed, “Is that how long you normally last? I was going to give you a blowjob, but perhaps Jen and I should spend our time on Derek…”

Jennifer’s ears perked up when she heard this. She still had a hand on Derek’s massive rod and she felt an overwhelming desire to please this sexy stud. Almost compulsively, she lifted up Derek’s cock and started gently licking his balls, which were also quite a bit larger than Nick’s.

“Oh fuck,” Derek moaned. Stacey went over and started licking Derek’s other testicle as she and Stacey each stroked his shaft with one hand.

Nick had no idea how Derek wasn’t cumming right now. His own pecker was already hard as a rock, but he had to stroke it himself as he watched from the sidelines.

After worshiping Derek’s nutsack, Jennifer and Stacey went for the main course. They gave each other a quick kiss before slowly tonguing the sides of Derek’s shaft. Derek was enjoying the tongue bath, but as his testosterone skyrocketed, he also felt the need to shove his dick in a nice, wet hole. He grabbed his cock and pointed it right at Jennifer’s mouth. With his other hand, he grabbed the back of her head and brought her mouth closer. Obediently, she opened wide and took the head of his meat.

“Oh shit, Nick, your girlfriend is so fucking hot!” Derek’s words sent Nick over the edge and he came again as he saw Derek’s cock enter Jennifer’s mouth. Derek smiled at the senior quarterback who was cumming from watching his rival fuck his girlfriend’s mouth, then he refocused his attention to feeding his meat to the sexy senior.

“There you go babe, open up a bit wider.” Derek’s rod was so thick that Jennifer was having a tough time making it a third of the way down. Her petite mouth was stretched to the limit, but she wanted so desperately to make Derek happy. As she opened her throat, Derek’s cock slid down past the five-inch mark. It was now in uncharted territory: Nick’s penis had never reached that far.

As Jennifer chocked and struggled, she felt a warm caress between her legs. She looked down and saw that Stacey was fingering her. Stacey moved her head closer to Jennifer’s pussy and dove in for a few licks. Holy shit, she thought. Stacey seemed to be an expert at this. She was making Jennifer squirm in ways that Nick had never done.

While Nick watched from the sidelines, Jennifer was convulsing with pleasure. Stacey made her cum again and again as she bobbed up and down on Derek’s dick. She couldn’t take all of it, but when she repressed her gag reflex and opened wide, she was able to handle about seven inches. Her hands did the rest of the work and she continued to massage the base of Derek’s rod and his massive balls.

For Nick, who was watching from five feet away, this was the best show of his life. Here was the hottest girl in the school, pleasuring his girlfriend. He desperately wished that the huge hunk of meat that his girlfriend was pleasuring belonged to him, but Nick also admitted to himself that Derek was hotter than he was. The 18-year-old freshman was a stud: he had complete control of the situation and sweat glistened down his ripped body as his massive rod tried to invade Jennifer’s mouth.

After thirty minutes, Derek gave up on penetrating any further, so he pulled Stacey over and shoved his cock down her throat. Jennifer and Nick watched in awe as she swallowed almost all of it. Nick came for the fourth time of the evening and Jennifer jealously licked Derek’s balls until Derek pulled out of Stacey’s mouth and started cumming. He unleashed a torrent of semen, which covered Stacey and Jennifer’s faces, breasts, and torsos.

Derek pulled Jennifer up from her knees and gave her a long kiss. “Thanks for trying babe, next time maybe you’ll take the whole thing.” He squeezed her ass and winked at her, then he picked Stacey up off the floor and carried her into the guest bedroom to continue a night of fucking.

Left alone, Nick and Jennifer stared at each other in shock. For the last hour, they had been hypnotized by the freshman stud and now they were still horny. Jennifer pushed Nick onto his back on the couch and jumped on his cock. She rode him for two minutes, frustrated that he wasn’t any bigger, and she almost cried when he came after two minutes. “Dammit!” she said. “Lick this cum off of me!”

Jennifer was so horny and frustrated that she shoved her breasts in Nick’s face. And for some reason, Nick dove in and started licking off Derek’s cum. He then went down to her pussy and brought her to her sixth orgasm of the evening.

“Thanks honey, that was good,” she said. “Sorry tonight was so crazy, but I just can’t believe that Derek is so fucking hot. Do you think he would want to fuck me sometime?”

“Ummm…”

“Please honey. I love you, but I need his cock. Just let me try it once.”

Nick was torn. The last thing he wanted was for his rival to fuck his girlfriend, but he was so horny that Jennifer had him wrapped around her finger. More importantly, he almost wanted his rival to take his girlfriend. The shame, humiliation, and self-doubt caused by this freshman stud was turning into pleasure…it almost seemed natural, even desirable, that something should happen next.

“I’ll see what I can do,” he said, as he and Jennifer got into bed and fell asleep, exhausted from a sex-filled day.
 
The next morning, Nick woke up with a throbbing erection. He turned to see if Jennifer was in bed with him, but she wasn’t there. His thoughts drifted to his nightmare from the night before…his girlfriend and Stacey slobbering all over Derek-the-sexy-freshman’s giant dick.

Oh shit, he realized, that wasn’t a dream. Jennifer had really asked him if he would ask Derek to fuck her. Nick groaned at the thought, but he was also incredibly turned on. He gave his woodie a few tugs while thinking about Derek fucking his girlfriend.

What would her moans sound like when Derek penetrated her with his massive rod? Would she orgasm as soon as he entered her? How could a tiny girl like Jennifer even take 9.5 inches? Stacey didn’t seem to have much trouble with it, but she was also built like a porn star. Maybe Nick could fuck Stacey while Derek fucked Jennifer. But Nick doubted this would happen. Why would Stacey want him to fuck her after riding such a stallion? Derek has enough man meat for both of the girls…such a long, thick, throbbing member. He also has those big, low-hanging balls that Jennifer kissed and caressed. As Nick wondered what those beautiful orbs would taste like, he fervently jerked his dick and shot his load into a tissue.

After his penis shriveled up to its normal state, Nick threw on some boxers and athletic shorts and headed downstairs. He ran into Jennifer in the kitchen, who was cooking breakfast in a thong and matching bra.

“Damn girl, you look great! Are you cooking me breakfast?” Nick asked.

“Umm…actually, I was making some for Derek, but we might have some leftovers.”
Surprised and frustrated, Nick poured himself a cup of coffee and sat down at the table. Just then Derek walked in and smiled to Jennifer, “Hey babe, breakfast smells great!” The freshman stud looked like a model for Abercrombie and Fitch. He was wearing Abercrombie boxers which had a prominent bulge and his chiseled muscles looked like they were sculpted by Michelangelo. His hair was also perfectly disheveled as a result of fucking Stacey for half the night and Nick could smell his manly, Alpine body odor.

“Where’s Stacey?” Nick asked. “She’s not coming down for breakfast?”

“She’s still recovering from last night,” Derek said, grinning and winking at Jennifer.

Nick watched in disgust as Derek ate the frittata that Jennifer had cooked for him. “Jen, this breakfast is delicious,” Derek said. “Nick, you sure are a lucky boy for having a beautiful, sexy, and amazing girlfriend.” While Jennifer swooned at the compliment, Nick felt like he was going to throw up. “I have to go,” he said.

As Nick gathered up his things and left Stacey’s house to go home, he gave Jennifer a quick peck on the cheek. “Honey, do you want to come home with me?” he asked.

“Ummm…I think I’m going to stay here and go shopping with Stacey later. I’ll call you tonight.”

“Okay, see ya.” As Nick left the house, Derek looked at Jennifer and licked his lips. This is gonna be a fun day, he thought.
 
Nick spent the next 24 hours trying to get his head straight. He tried to think about football, but every time he did, he remembered Saturday’s horrible game and how Derek had been the star. But whenever he thought about Jennifer or Stacey, all he could think about was Derek’s enormous dick and how Jennifer wanted to fuck him.

This thought repulsed him, but it also turned him on like crazy. While hanging out in his dorm room all afternoon and evening, Nick jerked off seven times. He hadn’t masturbated this much since when he was thirteen and had just picked up the habit. What am I doing? He thought. Here was a 22-year-old senior college football star jerking his cock like a little boy to thoughts of an 18-year-old fucking his girlfriend. He became more disgusted the more he thought about it, but that just made him hornier. He remembered how humiliated he felt when Jennifer measured his cock and then had to use both of her hands to get Derek fully aroused. He then remembered cumming prematurely as Jennifer choked on Derek’s rod. She hadn’t even asked me for permission, he thought. She just dove onto his meat like a whore.

Nick imagined what humiliating things Derek would do to him as he fucked Jennifer. Would Nick be allowed to touch his dick as he watched? Would he have to clean up Jennifer’s pussy and eat Derek’s sperm? Would he have to lick Jennifer’s juices off of Derek’s dick? Or lick his balls?

These thoughts caused Nick to ejaculate for the eighth time at one in the morning. Afterwards, he was finally able to fall asleep with thoughts of Derek’s cock swirling around his head.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BigNavy