Fuck, Marry, Kill

[Breathfromanother]

F: Charlie Hunnam (current)
M: Robert Gant
K: Jonny Sibilly

Turkish actors
Can Yaman
Caglar Ertugrul
Burak Celik

 

[mrmister1]

F: Burak Celik
M: Caglar Ertugrul
K: Can Yaman

Actors that played Spiderman
Tobey Maguire
Andrew Garfield
Tom Holland

 

[Breathfromanother]

I actually don't want to kill any of them, but for the sake of the game...

F: Andrew Garfield
M: Tom Holland
K: Tobey Maguire

TV Werewolves
Brandon Quinn
Joe Manganiello
Michael Trevino

 

[glorificus]

F: Brandon Quinn
M: Joe Manganiello
K: Michael Trevino (after sex, of course)

Crazy Roman Emperors
Elegabalus
Caligula
Nero

 

[mrmister1]

F: Caligula
M: Elagabalus
K: Nero

Hockey Players
Sidney Crosby
Carey Price
Ryan Murray

 

[Breathfromanother]

F: Carey Price
M: Sidney Crosby
K: Ryan Murray

Former One Directioners
Harry Styles (pre-tattoos)
Louis Tomlinson (also pre-tattoos)
Niall Horan

 

[mrmister1]

F: Niall Horan
M: Harry Styles
K: Louis Tomlinson

TV Cartoon Daddies
Homer Simpson
Peter Griffin
Hank Hill

 

[aiaiaioh]

F: Peter Griffin
M: Homer Simpson
K: Hank Hill

other Chrises:

Chris Kline
Chris Rock
Chris Martin

 

[mrmister1]

F: Chris Martin
M: Chris Rock
K: Chris Kline

Actors that played James Bond
Daniel Craig
Pierce Brosnan
Sean Connery

 

[Diego69]

FPierce Brosnan
MDaniel Craig
K:Sean Connery

Soap Opera:
Vincent Irizarry
Don Diamont
Jordi Vilasuso

 

[glorificus]

F: Don Diamont
M: Jordi Vilasuso
K: Vincent Irizarry

Hallmark Gays:
Jonathan Bennett
Peter Porte
Luke McFarlane

 

[mrmister1]

F: Peter Porte
M: Luke McFarlane
K: Jonathan Bennett

Star Wars Characters
Anakin Skywalker
Han Solo
Obi-Wan Kenobi

 

[aiaiaioh]

F: Han Solo
M: Obi-Wan Kenobi
K: Anakin Skywalker

Actors who played Batman
Micheal Keaton
Christian Bale
Ben Affleck

 

[glorificus]

F: Ben Affleck
M: Christian Bale (American Psycho-era or Batman-era)
K: Michael Keaton

Disney Princes:
Prince Charming
Prince Phillip
Prince Eric

 

[deleted11219221]

F: Phillip
M: Eric
K: Charming

1: Rock
2: Scissors
3: Paper

 

[viscountwxyz]

F: Paper
M: Scissors
K: Rock
(Weird flex, but okey-dokey...)

Gilbert Gottfried
Piers Morgan
Sanjaya Malakar
(Have fun with this one. )

 

[mrmister1]

F: Gilbert Gottfried
M: Sanjaya Malakar
K: Piers Morgan

Vampire Diaries Leading Men
Ian Somerhalder
Paul Wesley
Matt Davis

 

[explosionerection]

F: Gilbert Gottfried
M: Sanjaya Malakar
K: Piers Morgan

Vampire Diaries Leading Men
Ian Somerhalder
Paul Wesley
Matt Davis

F: Ian Somerhalder
M: Paul Wesley
K: Matt Davis

What about:
Ryan Gosling
Daniel Craig
Justin Bieber

 

[glorificus]

F: Daniel Craig (in 2000's bond era)
M: Ryan Gosling
K: that Canadian thing

Sean Cody super stars (at their peak hotness)
Brandon
Stu
Jamie

 

[mrmister1]

Full honesty, I don't really know any of these guys (don't watch sean cody) but based purely on my google search today......
F: Stu
M: Jamie
K: Brandon

Love Triangle of Looking (HBO TV Show)
Jonathan Groff
Russell Tovey
Raúl Castillo