Ian Hecox

Honestly, I think he's become more attractive than Anthony. Still like them both.
He always was just had a weird haircut lol. I never saw even back then how anthony was the "hot" one
 
I don't mean to clown on him, but imagine your roommate is hyping up a date, gives you text updates about how great the guy is so you don't have to worry, decides they're gonna do a second date, and then Ian Hecox brings them home.