This list ignores the hundreds of other actors who didn't make it as far as this group. Furthermore, none of them has had the success of any straight mainstream actor on film or tv. The reason why we know who this group is off the top of our heads is that there haven't really been that many new gay actors booking even the roles that they've managed to. Mindhunter has been canceled for a while, Whishaw doesn't have American film or tv success, Quinto did Star Trek and has been making his own projects for years so someone will hire him and Luke Evans is mostly a blip. Unless you're NPH, Matt Bomer or Jim Parsons then good luck.
Does being out in Hollywood end careers? Not if you're above a certain point where you've already managed to book notable roles. Does it make it a lot harder? Yes, it does. No gay actor on that list has said otherwise.
My perspective on Julian is that he's out. He's absolutely not hiding anything. Anyone that follows him could guess he's out. He hasn't said, "I'm gay" because it's obvious. He's not treating anyone like they're dumb and like he needs to say it.
Straight people don't have to write an essay proclaiming their sexuality and he's simply taking that route until someone asks him directly in an interview and he's ready to talk about it. (And even then I can see him mentioning Landon and not dwelling on anything.) I doubt he's being pressured or he wouldn't be as open as he is on Instagram. A publicist would have absolutely shut that down a long time ago. He just may not want to make it anyone else's business beyond what he posts there.
I'm going to start with your last point, that he's just being silent "until he's directly asked" about his sexuality. No one is ever going to ask that in a dignified interview about work. But he
was asked to comment on playing a gay role and dodged that question in an interview about
The Man in the Orange Shirt.
But you are now arguing with something I never wrote - this idea that most actors or no actor's careers would "be" harmed by being out. I made no such claim. I said it depends on the actor and many have done well and are out and doing better than Julian in the current climate. You even added to the list with actors I didn't mention and there are more, but again, that's not the issue. Most aspiring actors fail to become stars regardless of their sexuality and truly closeted and successful actors – unlike Julian – have a hard time proving otherwise until they come out.
But since you chose to go negative on openly gay actors to defend Julian, you should have clicked those links and really processed the credits of Evans, Whishaw, Groff and Quinto. All of them have
more work in bigger projects scheduled than Julian. You discredit Whishaw's and Evans' work, but as I wrote Julian's last big credits with significant screen time were BBC productions (2017), and not US productions. And as for dismissing Evans and Whishaw – Whishaw had a lead role in
Mary Poppins Returns (Disney no less), had a recurring role in the US series
Fargo in 2020 and has been playing Q for years in the
Bond films, with more TV and film in the works. Evans had the
Hobbit film series, has just come off of two successful crime dramas and has three films in the works and a series with Nicole Kidman, Melissa McCarthy etc. Groff will be in the
Matrix, Quinto in the new
Trek, etc –big US films.
But let's deal with your claim is that Julan is "out" and that it's "obvious" he's gay.
I have always agreed with this. My point has consistently been that that he
is already effectively out - openly political on gay and trans rights ... and his relationship .... and Pride ... and posing nude for a homoerotic magazine (
Yummy) ... and so on. Based on his credits and your reasoning, I'm surprised you're not arguing that it's hurt his career and that explains why he hasn't major work in a few years. I'm arguing the opposite, that he has been out and therefore it was odd that he declined to just give some indication that he had a connection to a gay role when given how otherwise bold he is on social media.
In fact, I'll maintain if he did and integrated his more sexual and liberated social media persona into his work he'd get even more work.
But you're arguing with things I did not say about him or gay actors as a rule.