Love KOTOR. Although the first one you couldn't really end up being bad as the Jedi council fixed that for Revan. If you want some fun, play that game again but name yourself Revan. LOL
The second one, I've got to say, if I had a Jedi boyfriend, Atton Rand would be it. That entire game is a blast. I hope more come out along those lines.
I liked SW: The Force Unleashed. Not a whole hell of a lot in character developement but a fun mindless way to kill some time. The sequel was disappointing in that it was WAY to short in game play. SPOILER ALERT...,,
I think Starkiller in the second game is the original Starkiller, not a clone like the sub-plot was leading up to. Everyone knows that you can't clone a Jedi, the force won't allow it. My view is reinforced with the Dark Jedi ending. The second Starkiller has no passion and no personality just acts like an automaton.
Sklar