I thought some really good reaction movies were from the "Her First Big Cock" site way back when they just got started, like maybe the first year. The girls seemed a lot more "real" both physically and in their reactions. Not that I don't love the Deisel & Sledge videos, but there were a few early HFBC vids that the scenario actually seemed "real." The DVD's from HFBC don't go all the way back to the beginning...does anyone know if those vids are available anywhere?
Also, I don't remember which one...but in one of the "There's Something About Jack" vids there's a scene with an actress (don't remember her name...I think she was hispanic) and in it she gives the typical fake-awed reaction to Jack's cock. At the end of the video they show an outtake of the first time she actually sees his cock...and the reaction is awesome! A mixture of shock, fear, and amusement...she pushes him away saying "No! I'm gonna go home all wide and I'll never have a boyfriend!" And then reluctantly gives in. Knowing her true reaction made the sex scene much more exciting! When I saw it I couldn't believe they chose the tepid, fake reaction over the real one. Don't these people know their audience?