First time experience masturbating with a butt plug in, a story and some questions

[golgafrincham24]

I'm a straight guy and never done any anal play or anything. Based on reading about how much guys seem to like it I decided to try masturbating with a butt plug. I went and bought one that's about 3" long and billed as a "beginner plug", I would estimate it is about the size of my finger although it has a couple of knobs on it.

Anyway I washed my ass and lay down, then spent a good while just stimulating my inner thighs, balls, and taint, and brushing my anus. It all felt pretty good. I was really hard, but I did not touch the dick yet. Then I lubed up the plug and started easing the first half inch in and out, in and out. It felt really good! Not as good as jacking my cock, but still good.

I then eased the whole thing in and started touching my penis. I felt filled up, a very diffrent feeling than I have ever had before. It didn't feel especially good, but not bad either. Just full. I started jacking my cock, and using my hips and left hand to work the butt plug around, while my left wrist lay across my balls massaging them. It all felt reallllly good, I wouldn't say better than just a normal masturbation session, but good sort of in a way I've never felt before. I think there were some spots where I had the pressure that felt especially good, but I couldn't tell.

Anyway as I got closer and closer to cumming, the "new good" feeling and the "usual" feeling kind of began to merge and felt reallly good together. Then I blew my load and there was a ton of semen, in fact I shot myself in the face which basically never happens.

So my main question is, is this how it's supposed to feel or should I keep trying to try to get some other feeling? It's a lot of clean up and stuff when I could have just done a normal jackoff session, and I don't think I really enjoyed it any more. Should I keep going? Any tips to make it feel especially good?

 

[BillM]

Stud, Well it sounds like your first experience was pretty nice and a longer butt plug may bring you even more pleasure and of course the real thing would would be awesome!!

 

[golgafrincham24]

Haha not really turned on by a gay experience! Well....maybe if the guy was like a hairless male model! But I would not be opposed to my wife pegging me if she wants to! Just want to figure out how to enjoy it more!

 

[CUBE]

I'm a straight guy and never done any anal play or anything. Based on reading about how much guys seem to like it I decided to try masturbating with a butt plug. I went and bought one that's about 3" long and billed as a "beginner plug", I would estimate it is about the size of my finger although it has a couple of knobs on it.

Anyway I washed my ass and lay down, then spent a good while just stimulating my inner thighs, balls, and taint, and brushing my anus. It all felt pretty good. I was really hard, but I did not touch the dick yet. Then I lubed up the plug and started easing the first half inch in and out, in and out. It felt really good! Not as good as jacking my cock, but still good.

I then eased the whole thing in and started touching my penis. I felt filled up, a very diffrent feeling than I have ever had before. It didn't feel especially good, but not bad either. Just full. I started jacking my cock, and using my hips and left hand to work the butt plug around, while my left wrist lay across my balls massaging them. It all felt reallllly good, I wouldn't say better than just a normal masturbation session, but good sort of in a way I've never felt before. I think there were some spots where I had the pressure that felt especially good, but I couldn't tell.

Anyway as I got closer and closer to cumming, the "new good" feeling and the "usual" feeling kind of began to merge and felt reallly good together. Then I blew my load and there was a ton of semen, in fact I shot myself in the face which basically never happens.

So my main question is, is this how it's supposed to feel or should I keep trying to try to get some other feeling? It's a lot of clean up and stuff when I could have just done a normal jackoff session, and I don't think I really enjoyed it any more. Should I keep going? Any tips to make it feel especially good?

Cool that you explored it. I think it’s a new sensation you need to explore it abit more. It’s part of a repitore you’re developing

 

[deleted300444]

I'm a straight guy and never done any anal play or anything. Based on reading about how much guys seem to like it I decided to try masturbating with a butt plug. I went and bought one that's about 3" long and billed as a "beginner plug", I would estimate it is about the size of my finger although it has a couple of knobs on it.

Anyway I washed my ass and lay down, then spent a good while just stimulating my inner thighs, balls, and taint, and brushing my anus. It all felt pretty good. I was really hard, but I did not touch the dick yet. Then I lubed up the plug and started easing the first half inch in and out, in and out. It felt really good! Not as good as jacking my cock, but still good.

I then eased the whole thing in and started touching my penis. I felt filled up, a very diffrent feeling than I have ever had before. It didn't feel especially good, but not bad either. Just full. I started jacking my cock, and using my hips and left hand to work the butt plug around, while my left wrist lay across my balls massaging them. It all felt reallllly good, I wouldn't say better than just a normal masturbation session, but good sort of in a way I've never felt before. I think there were some spots where I had the pressure that felt especially good, but I couldn't tell.

Anyway as I got closer and closer to cumming, the "new good" feeling and the "usual" feeling kind of began to merge and felt reallly good together. Then I blew my load and there was a ton of semen, in fact I shot myself in the face which basically never happens.

So my main question is, is this how it's supposed to feel or should I keep trying to try to get some other feeling? It's a lot of clean up and stuff when I could have just done a normal jackoff session, and I don't think I really enjoyed it any more. Should I keep going? Any tips to make it feel especially good?

Just continue to try it, experience it. Grind down, move hips....a lot of what you described. Prostate play is so undervalued and misunderstood. But plug. ice. Try a aneros prostate massager. Bot battery vibrating and non vibrating. Have a good time with it.

 

[BBB2.5]

Bravo for exploring your bottom side. It does not matter if your Straight or Gay. Playing your or having your ass played with can bring a lot of fun to the normal jack off session. There is not right or wrong sensation. That is unless it hurts you, then you should stop. It sounds like you enjoyed it ..
" the "new good" feeling and the "usual" feeling kind of began to merge and felt reallly good together. Then I blew my load and there was a ton of semen, in fact I shot myself in the face which basically never happens"

I think you should continue your bottom exploration. Try fucking yourself with the plug, that should bring a different sensation. I would even suggest you get different sizes. Thickness can defiantly bring a whole new feeling of "Fullness", which I like very much. Length can also take you to a different level of ass play... What ever you decide, just keep at it.... hopefully you will have more cum shots to the face.... Just have fun...

 

[Mister2101]

i agree with what everyone has said. Sounds like you enjoyed yourself.....and yes....it can only get better. Size, length and width of plug, dildo or vibrator......angle and depth of penetration...different positions for insertion.....can all increase the intimacy and pleasure you feel.....

I also think that the more you play with and stimulate your prostrate, the more intense the pleasure becomes. As I look back over the years, my ass and prostrate are so much more sensitive now than when I first started.....I know my body and I know what "works" for me and my ass.....and what feels really, really good......

Happy for you bro!! Please continue and keep us posted....others may learn from your experiences.....

 

[halcyondays]

I'm glad you had fun with it. It's really good that you started small. A common mistake is to go too big too fast and experience too much pain to want to explore further. You have avoided that.

Your butt is normally exit only. Insertion feels unusual but is worth it for prostate stimulation. Your orgasm sounded epic. My advice is to gradually increase the size of the toys you insert.

I started out with a small butt plug and quickly went to a medium plug of a three plug set. It took longer to adjust to the large plug. It's large girth really stretched my hole which was painful enough at first that I limited the amount of time I used it. There was no rush. Few minutes on, few minutes off, I gradually became accustomed to stretching my hole over several sessions.

My tip to make it feel better is to size up to a dildo. I started with an average cock size, just 6 inches long with 5 insertable with average girth. The advantage of this is the length of the shaft sliding back and forth over the prostate which drives me wild. Butt plugs aren't long enough to give this effect. My current dildo is 8 inches but I've used as big as foot longs.

If it seems like a lot of work to clean yourself out at first you'll get faster at it the more you do it.

Last point: most of the time I masturbate cock only. I go back door only when I have hankering for it.

 

[bighosenow]

I bought one of the new Hush butt plugs. They vibrate at about 5 different speeds plus have some fun wave patterns. They are controlled from a bluetooth app from ur smart phone. They come in 2 sizes. I have never been into anal play so I thought I should start with the smaller one....I'm sort embarrassed to report that the small one would fall out when running at high speed. The large one requires a little more effort to insert but doesn't fall out in use. It does produce mind blowing orgasms...and no the vendor wouldn't exchange them.