flaccid/erect poll

[fournineteenfiftynine]

If you only had these two choices, which would you choose:

5 inches flaccid and 6.5 inches erect
2.5 inches flaccid and 8 inches erect

??

 

[B_dxjnorto]

You need more choices. 2.5 flaccid and 8 erect would be a package deal if you had a nice long foreskin to go with it.

 

[Henryclan]

Given your choices and my current size (about 4" erect)...I'd love to be 5" flaccid and 6.5" erect. Sounds wonderful to me.

 

[silvertriumph2]

That was easy. The second one!

 

[B_andyo]

sorry but the impression after it gets to 8 inches is much better !

 

[avantgarde]

really difficult question...what's the girth on both?

6.5x6.5 would get the job done well enough, i think, with just about any woman. however an 8x4.5 would not be something i'd be willing to swap out with.

good question. I'll withhold answering until the "girth" is addressed.

 

[B_andyo]

yes... i would get 6.5x6.5 over a 8x4.5 any time.. even a 5.5 girth ...

but 8x6 ?

whats better a 8x6 or a 7x6.5 hehe

 

[Bill Blaskey]

if girth is over 6 for both I think I would be fine with either.

 

[gcbenji0]

the second one describes me almost acurately, and i wouldn't have it any other way. actually when i'm super flaccid, i can be less that 2" length and probably about 1 girth.
and yes, i've been laughed at for having a small penis because of my miniscule flaccid. but id rather have the goods and nobody know; rather than not have the goods and everyone thinks i do.

 

[fournineteenfiftynine]

Let's assume moderate girth whatever that is for both.

 

[frizzle]

What are you going to do with a flaccid cock?

 

[D_Harry_S_Taint]

did your wife ask that ?

 

[Gonad]

That is a really really tough one! I'm trying to imagine that some all-powerful cosmic force were asking me the question and my answer would really determine my future manhood. In that case...It's a really tough choice.

Right now I'm about 4 inches flaccid and 8 inches erect on a good day. I really really like having a big erection, but 2.5 inches flaccid is so very tiny...

I'm going to have to go with 5 inches flaccid, 6.5 erect.

 

[frizzle]

did your wife ask that ?

Nope, yours did. If looks could kill :biggrin1:

 

[eric_bauer89]

who in the hell would prefer a bigger flaccid dick than a bigger erect dick? i think that my smallest flaccid moment im like 3-4" but i grow out to be 8" erect...and IM DAMN PROUD OF IT!

 

[fournineteenfiftynine]

I think it is a tough question for some. A 6.5 inch erect penis is what many women would call ideal. A guy with a 5 inch flaccid cock will also often be one of the biggest in the locker room. So it is kind of the best of both worlds. A 2.5 inch flaccid cock would really be viewed as pretty small in the locker room and wouldn't allow any bulge in speedos, etc... Yet if it grew to 8 inches erect, would that make up for it? It is an interesting dillema I think - but I came up with the question so of course I would.

 

[D_Harry_S_Taint]

You just need to get once a strong hard-on in the locker room or in your speedo

then the legend will run by herself

 

[D_Roland_D_Hay]

I would go for the second option and blame the small flacid penis on shrinkage due to the cold...or perhaps my semi would be five inches and I would constantly fluff...the possibilities seem endless (hah).