Hmmm, let's see. ...
I suppose I am spoiled. I was once told by a girlfriend to get the men in my family together to make a calendar and I could be sitting on easy street! LOL! I think really it has to hit me. I think the word that describes some of MC's picks applied here: feral. That untameable quality that may not even be exhibited on the surface but you feel it unconscously . So it has very little with physical features. Many of them are not at all pretty, but have that inner something that makes them intriguing, pantherlike. Christopher Walken, Kevin Spacey, Rufus Sewell, Ian Mc Shane, Gabriel Byrne,Morgan Freeman,Matthew Mc Connaughey, Russell Wong,Omar Epps, MIchael Kane, Robert De Niro, Sean Connery, Jason Isaacs,Joaquin Phoenix, Ray Liotta, Samuel L. Jackson to name a few.
I also like men with a sense of their own style, "the male peacock" so to speak. I think that is why Johnny Depp is a proverbial favorite, He looks as if he came straight out of the Restoration period.
Back to you original question. I like thick eyebrows, stunning eyes, strong features, they dont have to be physically perfect, But I do like to see someone who cares about themselves....