Lex
Expert Member
- Joined
- Jun 11, 2004
- Posts
- 8,253
- Media
- 0
- Likes
- 118
- Points
- 268
- Location
- In Your Darkest Thoughts and Dreams
- Sexuality
- 99% Gay, 1% Straight
- Gender
- Male
- Lex,
SurferGirlCA said:I didn't think that when I saw it, actually. I assumed the scene in Ennis's head was just a reflection of his own experience that being "queer" = violent death. Maybe someone who has read the story can tell us if Annie Proulx makes it clear there. I kinda like that Ang Lee left it open to interpretation.
I read the story and saw the movie. I felt that is was clear from reading the story that what Ennis "sees" is what really happened. The actress' delivery in the movie makes it clear as well. She is lying (coldly) [the author notes this in the sotry] and Ennis knows this. He sees Jack's death as it really happened--a reenactment of what happened to the two men that got killed--not as it is told. His dad took him to see the corpse, remember?
The scene is a validation of Ennis's beliefs that being queer = a violent death. This is also why he is so upset when Alma confronts him. He does not know that she ever saw he and Jack kiss on the stairs that day. So, to him (and his deep-rooted, homophobic self-hatred), it caused him to believe (incorrectly in his case) that people can "See" that he is gay.
There is really no other end for Jack. he was more openly queer and took more risks to explore and meet his own needs. I need to see this again.