Dude, I am going to try to take this seriously, but it's really hard to, because no one, myself included, has said at any point that you should be into "feminine" guys (whatever that means". So to repeat, no one said that. No one, I mean no one is pissed off because of your preferences. I don't care who you fuck bro, or who Sony fucks. I just hope you are and not just talking about it here because that will legit make me sad.
If you truly don't understand what the issue is, you can just say so. But dismissing all those voices as "screaming" just says to me you didn't read any of it, and if you did, you didn't understand it (and the fact that you don't understand the basic point being made nor how it is being made is a good bit of evidence supporting this claim). The issue is language, tone, and being unnecessarily hurtful either intentionally or unintentionally to members of the site and of the community.
You, nor anyone else is mandated or forced to think of other people in the day to day, but surely it isn't necessary to complain about and diss so called effeminacy in order to say you like traditionally masculine men? if it is, and that makes sense to you, then so be it, makes none to me and never will. If the OP had just said, you know what, I can dial back a bit we wouldn't be here, but he didn't and instead threw gas on the fire. I grew up fighting for our rights and I will always stand for those who are marginalized even in our own community.
This response is almost entirely not about your likes but your dislikes. This thread has a title that has nothing about women, effeminacy, transwomen, and is rather about being into butch dudes. When gay men talk about turn offs, that is a turn off. No one finds those comments sexy or useful. My suggestion is to share more about the men you like (instead of just "not a lumberjack") as that is what the thread is about, not "ew heels drag ew gross". You can see my point here? At the end of the day, you don't have to stop talking about effeminacy being a turn off, although insisting on making it part of your everyday rhetoric of sex is to me a ridiculous waste of time and at odds with the goal of landing a dude who is trad masc.
Here's a shot of me, just so you get a sense of what the 6'3", 245 lb man who wrote this looks like.
View attachment 1552386