I for one do not know for sure if philpeg's photos are fakes. I do question them, since he says he took them with a cellphone, but obviously someone else was holding the cellphone because he's posed over chairs and tables, etc.
If in fact it's real, it's a fantastic cock. Hard as a rock and seems to stay that way. I'd like to hear some stories about a few personal experiences with it.
As far as criticizing his vanity is concerned, I suggest that people who live in glass houses should't be throwing stones. What we have here is criticism of one photographer by another photographer, so how serious should I take that? Very few even seem to own a ruler. So, how about it, guys? How do you bitch abourt somebody twice as big as you are who does the same thing?
I also notice that the "Photoshop Card" is played every time somebody sees a dick they would like to have, themselves. So instead of playing the Photoshop card (which is really getting old, by now) and accusing contributors of lying, why don't the contributors take just one picture with a ruler, a tape measure, a bottle, a Pringle's can, or something we are familiar with first.
After that, they can talk all they want to about their cock, and we're going to respect it. Go ahead . It ain't braggin' if you can prove it.
This is a "Support Group" for all those poor souls disadvantaged with an exceptionally large cock, right? So, it happens then that the expected fettish is going to create either an inflated view of oneself, or the opposite-- a rejection of oneself, based on our natural reaction from what's normal. So then, let's support them and not react negatively to their own trap of such expressed pride of ownership. We can be gracious to everybody while still asking them to "prove it." Try a little respect. It works.
And then, IF in fact they have what they say they have, they will do so. After all, they were the ones making the claim, not us. So they should say, What kind of photo would you like?
Quite frankly, I personally don't think a 9 incher is awesome, but it sure makes for a good looking cock on a guy, especially when it's really hard. It's when you get over 10-11 inches that things start to become incredible. So while members seldom question a 9 incher, they jump on the owners of bigger dicks as Photoshopped." That's cheap, in my opinion, unless you can prove it.
So my suggestion is simple and obvious. Don't go accusing people of lying unless you can prove it. But there's absolutely nothing wrong with telling the guy to give us a legitimate photo with something in hand to measure it by.
90% of the photos are good for entertainment, but the burden of proof is on the contributor, and these photos of clothed penises wrapped around somebody's leg are just nonsense. I don't give them the benefit of the doubt, at all. We could all come up witth one of those, even Madame Zora.