Skinny Guinea
Experimental Member
Reasoning would say that the guys doing the dick waving were actually quite gay; how on earth did they think they were degrading the guy, making him "gay," or whatever, by making him sit on a block of ice while they waved their dicks at him? I mean, they're the ones who chose this activity!
But I think the issue here is power. The object is to objectify the other guy and humiliate him (even if in a joking way), with a sexual context involved.
If I may quote myself.... (Yes, I may.)
Reading through my post above, I realized something. To the male mind, the penis represents power. What is really going on in the situation with the naked guy sitting on the block of ice and the other guys waving their dicks in his face, is this: the other guys are saying, "We have the power and you don't! The penis represents power, and I am waving my power in your face! Meanwhile, you are naked, cold, and shivering, and your dick, the symbol of your power, is shrivelling and small."
If I take this reasoning and put it on to circle jerks, perhaps what it means is that at some level circle jerks are an acknowledgement that of each others' power. "We all have dicks. We all have power. I'm okay with the fact that you have a dick and are powerful." This is most likely what we mean by the "brotherly" aspect of it.
EDIT: Eerie coicidencence, but I am currently listening to the album I listened to with the two brothers I mentioned. We listened to it the day before we had the "circle jerk." I haven't had this album for years because my entire CD collection had been stolen. "I'm so happy, 'cus today I found my friends."